A cost effective approach to the investigation of syncope: relative merit of different diagnostic strategies

Abstract

Objective: To compare the cost effectiveness of a conventional diagnostic work-up with that of several different diagnostic cascades for the investigation of undifferentiated syncope.

Design: A MEDLINE search established a weighted estimate of diagnostic yield for several diagnostic investigations. 'High-end' and 'low-end' cost estimates were calculated for these investigations based on figures from four representative Canadian tertiary care centres in four different provinces. Several diagnostic models were applied to a hypothetical cohort of 100 patients with undifferentiated syncope.

Results: The conventional diagnostic cascade resulted in a diagnosis in 85% of patients, at a cost per diagnosis of $467 to $959. The optimal model increased the diagnostic yield to 98.9%, at a cost of $460 to $1043 per diagnosed patient.

Conclusion: A combination of new technology and selective use of investigations has the potential to raise diagnostic yield without appreciably increasing cost per diagnosis.