Semi-closed femoropopliteal thromboendarterectomy: a prospective study

Abstract

Objective: to study the primary patency rates of angioscopically controlled thromboendarterectomies of the superficial femoral artery.

Design: prospective open study.

Methods: between 1990 and 1995, femoropopliteal thromboendarterectomies were performed in 63 patients (41 male, 22 female). Postoperative follow up was performed at 3- to 6-month intervals using non-invasive pressure measurements plus IVDSA at 1 year.

Results: eight patients were not evaluable, leaving 55 patients eligible for follow-up analysis. Postoperative complications (arteriovenous fistulas, false aneurysms) were observed in 5.4% of patients. Immediate perioperative occlusions occurred in 7.3%, early occlusions in 21.8% and late occlusions in 16.4% of all cases. The mean follow-up was approximately 57 months. The mean primary patency rate at 5 years was 44.5% (28 patients with the superficial femoral artery still open). Six patients died during the follow-up period.

Conclusions: in contrast to the very positive reports found in recent literature, this prospective study shows a lower five-year patency rate for semi-closed femoropopliteal thromboendarterectomy than for bypass grafting. Thromboendarterectomy cannot be considered as a standard procedure in revascularisation of the femoropopliteal region.