Efficacy of methods for determining ovulation in a natural family planning program

Abstract

Objective: To evaluate the efficacy in ovulation detection of methods used in natural family planning in comparison with pelvic ultrasonography.

Design: Prospective analysis of ovulation detection by natural family planning methods and ultrasonography.

Setting: Natural family planning clinic, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Naples "Federico II".

Patient(s): Forty healthy women who were highly motivated to use natural family planning.

Intervention(s): None.

Main outcome measure(s): Transvaginal ultrasonographic findings, urinary LH levels, salivary beta-glucuronidase activity, salivary ferning levels and characteristics of cervical mucus, and BBT.

Result(s): Urinary LH level determination yielded a 100% correlation with the simultaneous ultrasonographic diagnosis of ovulation. Mucus sensations and characteristics yielded a 48.3% correlation when simultaneously evaluated with ovulation. Beta-glucuronidase levels yielded a 27.7% correlation. The salivary ferning test had a 36.8% ovulation-detection rate the day of ovulation, but 58.7% of results were uninterpretable. Body temperature measurements yielded a 30.4% correlation with the simultaneous ultrasonographic diagnosis of ovulation.

Conclusion(s): Measuring urinary LH levels is an excellent method for determining ovulation. Although variations in mucus characteristics and basal body temperature correlate somewhat with ovulation, the length of the fertile period is overestimated with these methods. The salivary ferning test and measurement of beta-glucuronidase levels are not good methods for home ovulation testing.

PIP: This methodological study aims to evaluate the efficacy of methods used for determining ovulation in a natural family planning in comparison with pelvic ultrasonography. Prospective analysis of ovulation detection methods was conducted with 40 women. Ovulation-detection methods employed in the study include transvaginal ultrasonography, daily morning urinary luteinizing hormone (LH) determinations, determination of salivary beta-glucuronidase activity, salivary ferning test, determination of cervical mucus levels and characteristics, and measurement of rectal or oral basal body temperature. Results revealed a 100% correlation between urinary LH level and ovulation diagnosis obtained from ultrasonographic examination. Other ovulation-detection methods contain the following correlation results: mucus sensations and characteristics, 48.3%; alpha-glucuronidase, 27.7%; and salivary ferning test, 36.8%. These findings draw the researchers to conclude that self-determination of LH levels could be an excellent method in ovulation determination.