Correlation between clinical and histologic patterns of degenerative mitral valve insufficiency: a histomorphometric study of 130 excised segments

Abstract

The objectives of this study were to examine quantitatively the histological changes in incompetent degenerative mitral valves obtained at surgery for mitral valve repair, and to determine whether Barlow's disease (BD) and fibroelastic deficiency (FED) can be distinguished by histology. The billowing mitral leaflet syndrome (or Barlow's disease) and FED can be distinguished on the basis of clinical patterns and gross features, but their histologic patterns have not been described. One hundred thirty patients were studied. Thirty-nine (24 males) had BD; 44 (38 males) FED; 15 (7 males) Marfan's syndrome (MS); and 32 patients (25 males) a non-determined degenerative disease. Histological changes of the resected segment of the valve were quantitatively evaluated using scores of severity. A discriminant analysis was performed. The groups defined by the computer were checked for concordance with groups defined by the surgeon. Collagen alterations were found the most severe in MS patients. BD and MS had the most myxoid infiltration. MS and FED patients had the most elastic fiber alterations. No BD in males and only one in females were misclassified by the discriminant procedure into the FED group. Overall, the percentages of correct matchings were 54% in males and 62% in females. When the age of patients and the size of ring were added to histology to determine whether this additional information provided more discrimination, the percentages of correct matchings reached 90% in males and 100% in females. BD and FED are two fairly distinct entities, which can be distinguished by quantitative histology, whereas only modest differences were found in qualitative histology.