Comparison of HIG scintigraphy and bloodpool scintigraphy using HDP in arthritic joint disease

Abstract

Aim: Because of a similar tracer accumulation, we assumed to get the same information about synovitis in arthritic joint disease with HIG scintigraphy and bloodpool scintigraphy using HDP. Therefore, we compared retrospectively 23 patients.

Methods: In HIG scintigraphy, synovitis was diagnosed according to increasing activity from early to late image. In bloodpool scintigraphy according to an increased activity in comparison to the surrounding tissues.

Results: In 694 joints comparison of both scintigraphic modalities was possible, resulting in a 2 x 2 kappa coefficient of 0.93 or 0.97 by using late-phase bone scintigraphy as an anatomical marker. For intra- and interobserver agreement, 2 x 2 kappa coefficients of 0.93 and 0.88 in HIG scintigraphy, respectively 0.96 and 0.90 in blood-pool scintigraphy were calculated.

Conclusion: This study shows an excellent agreement in the visualization of synovitis by HIG and bloodpool scintigraphy. Because of its higher objectivity and lower cost, investigation of synovitis should be performed by bloodpool scintigraphy.