Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
. 2000;2000(2):CD001163.
doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001163.

Seclusion and restraint for people with serious mental illnesses

E Sailas  1 , M Fenton
Affiliations

Seclusion and restraint for people with serious mental illnesses

E Sailas et al. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2000.

Abstract

Background: Seclusion and restraint are interventions used in the treatment and management of disruptive and violent behaviours in psychiatry. The use of seclusion varies widely across institutions. The literature does offer numerous suggestions for interventions to reduce or prevent aggression.

Objectives: 1. To estimate the effects of seclusion and restraint compared to the alternatives for those with serious mental illnesses. 2. To estimate the effects of strategies to prevent seclusion and restraint in those with serious mental illnesses.

Search strategy: Electronic searches of The Cochrane Controlled Trials Register (Issue 1, 1999) and The Cochrane Schizophrenia Group's Register (January 1999) were supplemented with additional searches of Biological Abstracts (1989-1999), CINAHL (1982-1999), EMbase (1980-1999), MEDLINE (1966-1999), MEDIC (1979-1999), PsycLIT (1974-1999), Sociofile (1974-1999), SPRI & SWEMED (1982-1999), Social Sciences Citation Index (1996-1999), and WILP (1983-1999). In addition, trials were sought by hand searching the reference lists of all identified studies and conference abstracts and contacting the first author of each relevant study.

Selection criteria: Randomised controlled trials were included if they focused on the use (i) of restraint or seclusion; or (ii) of strategies designed to reduce the need for restraint or seclusion in the treatment of serious mental illness.

Data collection and analysis: Studies were reliably selected, quality rated and data extracted. For dichotomous data relative risks (RR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were estimated. Normal continuous data were summated using the weighted mean difference (WMD).

Main results: 1. Effect of seclusion and restraint The search strategy yielded 2155 citations. Of these, the full articles for 35 studies were obtained. No studies met minimum inclusion criteria and no data were synthesised. Most of the 24 excluded studies focused upon the restraint of elderly, confused people and preventing them from wandering or falling. 2. Prevention of seclusion and restraint Work ongoing.

Reviewer's conclusions: No controlled studies exist that evaluate the value of seclusion or restraint in those with serious mental illness. There are reports of serious adverse effects for these techniques in qualitative reviews. Alternative ways of dealing with unwanted or harmful behaviours need to be developed. Continuing use of seclusion or restraint must therefore be questioned from within well-designed and reported randomised trials that are generalisable to routine practice.

PubMed Disclaimer

Conflict of interest statement

The reviewers believe that seclusion and restraint can be used to excess and that the least restrictive principle is often not sought.

References

References to studies excluded from this review

Alessi 1995 {published data only}
    1. Alessi CA, Schnelle JF, MacRae PG, Ouslander JG, Al Samarrai N, Simmons SF, Traub S. Does physical activity improve sleep in impaired nursing home residents?. Journal of the American Geriatric Society 1995;43:1098‐102. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Buckley 1997 {published data only}
    1. Buckley PF, Ibrahim ZY, Singer B, Orr B, Donenwirth K, Brar PS. Aggression and schizophrenia: efficacy of risperidone. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 1997;25(2):173‐81. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Clark 1995 {published data only}
    1. Clark LR, Fraaza V, Schroeder S, Maddens ME. Alternative nursing environments: do they affect hospital outcomes?. Journal of Gerontological Nursing 1995;21:32‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Cole 1994 {published data only}
    1. Cole MG, Primeau FJ, Bailey RF, Bonnycastle MJ, Masciarelli F, Engelsmann F, Pepin MJ, Ducic D. Systematic intervention for elderly inpatients with delirium: a randomized trial. Canadian Medical Association Journal 1994;151(7):965‐70. [MEDLINE: ] - PMC - PubMed
Collard 1985 {published data only}
    1. Collard AF, Bachman SS, Beatrice DF. Acute care delivery for the geriatric patient: an innovative approach. QRB Quality Review Bulletin 1985;11:180‐5. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Evans 1997 {published data only}
    1. Capezuti E, Evans L, Strumpf N, Maislin G. Physical restraint use and falls in nursing home residents. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1996;44(6):627‐33. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
    1. Capezuti E, Strumpf NE, Evans LK, Grisso JA, Maislin G. The relationship between physical restraint removal and falls and injuries among nursing home residents. Journals of Gerontology 1998;53(Series A ‐ Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences):47‐52. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
    1. Evans LK, Strumpf NE, Allen‐Taylor SL, Capezuti E, Maislin G, Jacobsen B. A clinical trial to reduce restraints in nursing homes. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1997;45(6):675‐81. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
    1. Kolanowski A, Hurwitz S, Taylor LA, Evans L, Strumpf N. Contextual factors associated with disturbing behaviors in institutionalized elders. Nursing Research 1994;43(2):73‐9. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
    1. Patterson JE, Strumpf NE, Evans LK. Nursing consultation to reduce restraints in a nursing home. Clinical Nurse Specialist 1995;9(4):231‐5. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Foxx 1996 {published data only}
    1. Foxx RM, McHenry IWC, Bremer BA. The effects of a video vignette on increasing treatment acceptability. Behavioral Interventions 1996;11:131‐40.
Frank 1996 {published data only}
    1. Frank C, Hodgetts G, Puxty J. Safety and efficacy of physical restraints for the elderly. Review of the evidence. Canadian Family Physician 1996;42:2402‐9. [MEDLINE: ] - PMC - PubMed
Gaebler 1994 {published data only}
    1. Gaebler S. Just who do we restrain?. Australian Nursing Journal 1994;2(1):39‐41. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Glazer 1998 {published data only}
    1. Glazer WM, Dickson RA. Clozapine reduces violence and persistent aggression in schizophrenia. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 1998;59(Suppl 3):8‐14. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Janelli 1997 {published data only}
    1. Janelli LM, Kanski GW. Music intervention with physically restrained patients. Rehabilitation Nursing 1997;22(1):14‐9. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Lewis 1996 {published data only}
    1. Lewis MH, Bodfish JW, Powell SB, Parker DE, Golden RN. Clomipramine treatment for self‐injurious‐behavior of individuals with mental retardation ‐ a double‐blind comparison with placebo. American Journal on Mental Retardation 1996;100(6):654‐65. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Moretz 1995 {published data only}
    1. Moretz C, Dommel A, Deluca K. Untied: a safe alternative to restraints. Medsurg Nursing 1995;4(2):128‐32. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Nijman 1997 {published data only}
    1. Nijman HL, Merckelbach HL, Allertz WF, a Campo JM. Prevention of aggressive incidents on a closed psychiatric ward. Psychiatric Services 1997;48(5):694‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Phillips 1995 {published data only}
    1. Phillips D, Rudestam KE. Effect of nonviolent self‐defense training on male psychiatric staff members' aggression and fear. Psychiatric Services 1995;46(2):164‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Roeggla 1997 {published data only}
    1. Roeggla M, Wagner A, Muellner M, Bur A, Roeggla H, Hirschl MM, Laggner AN, Roeggla G. Cardiorespiratory consequences to hobble restraint. Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift 1997;109(10):359‐61. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Rovner 1996 {published data only}
    1. Rovner BW, Steele CD, Shmuely Y, Folstein MF. A randomized trial of dementia care in nursing homes. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1996;44(1):7‐13. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Schnelle 1992 {published data only}
    1. Schnelle JF, Newman DR, White M, Volner TR, Burnett J, Cronqvist A, Ory M. Reducing and managing restraints in long‐term‐care facilities. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1992;40(4):381‐5. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Schnelle 1996 {published data only}
    1. Schnelle JF, MacRae PG, Giacobassi K, MacRae HS, Simmons SF, Ouslander JG. Exercise with physically restrained nursing home residents: maximizing benefits of restraint reduction. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1996;44(5):507‐12. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Silverman 1984 {published data only}
    1. Silverman K, Watanabe K, Marshall AM, Baer DM. Reducing self‐injury and corresponding self‐restraint through the strategic use of protective clothing. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 1984;17(4):545‐52. [MEDLINE: ] - PMC - PubMed
Stoudemire 1996 {published data only}
    1. Stoudemire A, Smith DA. OBRA regulations and the use of psychotropic drugs in long term care facilities ‐ impact and implications for geropsychiatric care. General Hospital Psychiatry 1996;18(2):77‐94. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Thapa 1996 {published data only}
    1. Thapa PB, Brockman KG, Gideon P, Fought RL, Ray WA. Injurious falls in nonambulatory nursing home residents ‐ a comparative study of circumstances, incidence, and risk factors. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 1996;44(3):273‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Thomas 1992 {published data only}
    1. Thomas H Jr, Schwartz E, Petrilli R. Droperidol versus haloperidol for chemical restraint of agitated and combative patients. Annals of Emergency Medicine 1992;21(4):407‐13. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Tutunjian 1963 {published data only}
    1. Tutunjian K, Guido JA. A new piperidine phenothiazine (pereracetazine) in chronic psychotic patients. American Journal of Psychiatry 1963;119:776‐7. - PubMed
Weinrich 1995 {published data only}
    1. Weinrich S, Egbert C, Eleazer GP, Haddock KS. Agitation: measurement, management, and intervention research. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing 1995;9(5):251‐60. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed

References to studies awaiting assessment

Bergk 2011 {published data only}
    1. Bergk J, Einsiedler B, Flammer E, Steinert T. A randomized controlled comparison of seclusion and mechanical restraint in inpatient settings. Psychiatric Services 2011;62(11):1310‐7. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
ISRCTN49454276 {published data only}
    1. Huf G, Coutinho ES, Adams CE. Physical restraints versus seclusion room for management of people with acute aggression or agitation due to psychotic illness (trec‐save): A randomized trial. Psychological Medicine 2012 Mar 12 [Epub ahead of print]. [DOI: 10.1017/S0033291712000372; MEDLINE: ] - DOI - PubMed
    1. Huf G, Coutinho ES, Ferreira MA, Ferreira S, Mello F, Adams CE. Trec‐save: A randomised trial comparing mechanical restraints with use of seclusion for aggressive or violent seriously mentally ill people: Study protocol for a randomised controlled trial. Trials 2011;12(1):180. [MEDLINE: ] - PMC - PubMed
    1. Huf G, Coutinho ESF. TREC‐SAVE1.A randomised trial comparing mechanical restraints with use of seclusion for aggressive or violent seriously mentally ill people. Data on file. - PMC - PubMed
    1. ISRCTN49454276. Trec‐save: A trial for aggressive or violent seriously mentally ill people. http://www.controlled‐trials.com 2011. - PMC - PubMed

Additional references

Altman 1996
    1. Altman DG, Bland JM. Detecing skewness from summary information. BMJ 1996;313:1200. [MEDLINE: ; SR020600] - PMC - PubMed
Angold 1989
    1. Angold A. Seclusion. British Journal of Psychiatry 1989;154:437‐44. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
APA 1985
    1. American Psychiatric Association. Seclusion and restraint: the psychiatric uses. Task Force Report 22. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1985.
Aschen 1995
    1. Aschen SR. Restraints: does position make a difference?. Issues in Mental Health Nursing 1995;16(1):87‐92. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Brown 1992
    1. Brown JS, Tooke SK. On the seclusion of psychiatric patients. Social Science and Medicine 1992;35(5):711‐21. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Chow 1996
    1. Chow E, Desai H, Bury AS, Roy R, Bassett AS, Collins EJ. The effects of clozapine on aggression: a randomized‐controlled study. 149th Annual Meeting of the American Psychiatric Association. May 4‐9, 1996.
Crenshaw 1997
    1. Crenshaw WB, Cain KA, Francis PS. An updated national survey on seclusion and restraint. Psychiatric Services 1997;48(3):395‐7. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Essock 1996
    1. Essock SM, Hargreaves WA, Covell NH, Goethe J. Clozapine's effectiveness for patients in state hospitals: results from a randomized trial. Psychopharmacology Bulletin 1996;32(4):683‐97. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Farnham 1997
    1. Farnham 1997. Acute excited states and sudden death. BMJ 1997;315(7116):1107‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PMC - PubMed
Fisher 1994
    1. Fisher WA. Restraint and seclusion: a review of the literature. American Journal of Psychiatry 1994;151(11):1584‐91. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Gerlock 1983
    1. Gerlock A, Solomon HC. Factors associated with the seclusion of psychiatric patients. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care 1983;21(2):46‐53. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Gudeman 1981
    1. Gudeman JE, Dickey B, Rood L, Hellman S, Grinspoon L. Alternative to the back ward: the quarterway house. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 1981;32(5):330‐4. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Gutheil 1995
    1. Gutheil TG. Legal issues in psychiatry. In: Kaplan HI, Sadock BJ editor(s). Comprehensive textbook of psychiatry. Sixth. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1995:2747‐66.
Höyer 1994
    1. Höyer G, Drange H. Changes in the use of compulsory measures in Norwegian psychiatric institutions [Utviklingen av tvangsmidlebruk i norske psykiatriske institusjoner]. Tidsskrift for Norske Laegeforening 1994;114(5):585‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Jadad 1996
    1. Jadad A, Moore A, Carroll D, Jenkinson C, Reynolds DJM, Gavanagh DJ, McQuay HJ. Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary?. Controlled Clinical Trials 1996;17(1):1‐12. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Kalogjera 1989
    1. Kalogjera IJ, Ashok B, Watson WN, Meyer AD. Impact of therapeutic management on use of seclusion and restraint with disruptive adolescent inpatients. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 1989;40(3):280‐5. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Mason 1993
    1. Mason T. Seclusion theory reviewed ‐ a benevolent or malevolent intervention?. Medicine, Science and the Law 1993;33(2):95‐102. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
McDonnell 1996
    1. McDonnell A, Reeves S. Phasing out seclusion through staff training and support. Nursing Times 1996;32(92):43‐4. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Mulrow 1999
    1. Mulrow CD, Oxman AD. Cochrane Collaboration Handbook [updated March 1999]. The Cochrane Library [database on disk and CDROM]. The Cochrane Collaboration.
Owen 1998
    1. Owen C, Tarantello C, Jones M, Tennnant C. Violence and aggression in psychiatric units. Psychiatric Services 1998;49(11):1452‐7. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Phillips 1995
    1. Phillips D, Rudestam KE. Effect of nonviolent self‐defense training on male psychiatrioc staff members' aggression and fear. Psychiatric Services 1995;46(2):164‐8. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Ray 1995
    1. Ray NK, Rappaport ME. Use of restraint and seclusion in psychiatric settings in New York State. Psychiatric Services 1995;46:1032‐7. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Salib 1998
    1. Salib E, Ahmed AG, Cope M. Practise of seclusion: a five‐year retrospective review in North Cheshire. Medicine, Science and the Law 1998;38(4):321‐7. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Shah 1991
    1. Shah AK, Fineberg NA, James DV. Violence among psychiatric inpatients. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 1991;84(4):305‐9. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Sommerness 1957
    1. Sommerness MD, Lucero RJ, Hamlon JS, Mahowald AM. Chlorpromazine: a controlled study with highly disturbed patients. Diseases of the Nervous System 1957;18:16‐20. - PubMed
Swett 1994
    1. Swett C. Inpatient seclusion: description and causes. Bulletin of American Academy of Psychiatry and Law 1994;22:421‐30. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Tardiff 1992
    1. Tardiff K. The current state of psychiatry in the treatment of violent patients. Archives of General Psychiatry 1992;49(6):493‐9. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Walsh 1995
    1. Walsh E, Randell B. Seclusion and restraint: what do we need to know?. Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing 1995;8(1):28‐40. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Way 1990
    1. Way BB, Banks SM. Use of seclusion and restraint in public psychiatric hospitals: patient characteristics and facility effects. Hospital and Community Psychiatry 1990;41(1):75‐81. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Whittington 1996
    1. Whittington R. An evaluation of staff training in psychological techniques for the management of patient aggression. Journal of Clinical Nursing 1996;5(4):257‐61. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed

Publication types

Substances