Comparison of short and long-term renal function in liver transplant patients receiving cyclosporin or FK 506

Abstract

Long-term renal function was compared in 49 liver recipients [25 patients received cyclosporin (CyA) and 24 patients received FK 506] followed for a period of 1 year. Creatinine (CR) and glomerular filtration rate (GFR) pretransplantation (pre-Tx) and at 1, 3, 5, and 12 months post-Tx were recorded, as well as incidences of hyperkalemia, post-Tx hypertension, and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) in the two groups. At 1 year post-Tx, the mean Cr had risen from baseline by 56% and 60% in the FK and CyA groups, respectively; the mean GFR had dropped by 32% in FK patients and by 27% in CyA patients. Acute nephrotoxicity occurred in 7/25 CyA patients (2/7 required dialysis) and 9/26 FK patients (7/9 required dialysis; 2/7 were switched to CyA). None remained on dialysis at 3 months. Renal insufficiency persisted at 1 year in 7/16 patients with early toxicity (CyA, 4; FK, 3) and in 3 of the remaining 36 pts (P < 0.001). Hyperkalemia occurred in 4/25 CyA, and in 12/24 FK patients (P < 0.025), post-Tx hypertension occurred in 15 CyA, and 7 FK patients (P < 0.05), and IDDM occurred in 4 CyA and 7 FK patients (P = ns). FK 506 and CyA, thus, exerted similar chronic renal effects. Although acute renal insufficiency improved upon dose reduction, renal impairment was permanent in some cases.