Unicondylar femoral fractures: therapeutic strategy and long-term results. A review of 23 patients

Abstract

Unicondylar femoral fractures account for 0.65% of all femoral fractures; they have not been studied extensively in the orthopedic literature. Usually occurring following sports trauma or traffic accidents, these fractures involve the lateral condyle three times more frequently than the medial condyle. Conservative or surgical treatment has been advocated, depending on the fracture type. From 1986 to 1999, 19 patients with unicondylar femoral fractures were surgically treated at our institution: there were 15 males and 4 females, aged 36.2 years on average. According to the AO-ASIF classification, there were 7 B1, 6 B2 and 6 B3 fractures. We used Herbert screws in six cases, Barr screws together with cancellous screws in two, cannulated screws in five, cancellous screws alone in four, a compression screw and plate in one and a T-plate in one. In the same period of time, four patients were treated conservatively with a cast. Sixteen patients treated surgically were evaluated with a mean follow-up of 60 months, using Shatzker and Lambert's criteria: six results were rated as excellent, five good, four fair and one poor, while conservative treatment gave three fair and one poor results. In conclusion, we think that open reduction and internal fixation are essential in the treatment of such fractures.