Abstract

NASA: The author examines conflicting models, especially evidence from Price and Schoell in this issue (see comment), for the creation of ore deposits and the movement of petroleum. The Bakken formation in North Dakota is used as an example of a petroleum reservoir that has not migrated from its original site. Analysis of natural gases at the site indicates a difference in gas distribution between the Bakken site and migratory sites. Controversies are examined in the context of advances in fluid-flow calculations and high-temperature methanogenic reactions.