Resection margin status in lumpectomy specimens for duct carcinoma of the breast: correlation with core biopsy and mammographic findings

Abstract

Background: The strategy for surgical treatment of breast carcinoma proven by biopsy is mainly based on the physical and mammographic examinations. To investigate if the pathological findings in core biopsy are contributory to planning the surgical strategy, we correlated the status of ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) in the core needle biopsy of breast, the mammographic changes and the status of resection margins in the subsequent lumpectomy.

Study design: Consecutive 130 core needle biopsies with prior mammography and subsequent lumpectomy were reviewed. Biopsies were divided into: group I, DCIS; group II, DCIS and infiltrating carcinoma (IC); and group III, IC. Mammographic findings were categorized into four groups: (a) nonspecific findings; (b) calcification (Ca(++)); Ca(++) and mass, and mass only. The status of margins in correlating lumpectomy specimens was reviewed. Close margin was defined as a free margin at less than 0.1cm from the carcinoma.

Results: The rates of positive or close margins in three groups I, II, and III were 13/18, 18/48, and 2/64 (P < 0.001); and in mammography groups of nonspecific finding, Ca(++), Ca(++) mass and mass only were 5/6, 7/15, 8/37, and 13/72 (P < 0.001), respectively. Of the total of 14 cases with positive margins of more than 0.5 cm in length, 8, 4, and 2 cases were from group I, II, and II, respectively. In addition, 13 of 21 cases with nonspecific changes or with only Ca(++) in mammograms belonged to the group I; 10 of these 13 cases were associated with positive margins. Forty-one of 72 cases presenting as a mass only in mammograms belonged to the group III; only 2 of these 41 cases were associated positive margins.

Conclusions: Correlation of the extent of carcinoma with pre-operative histopathological findings was better than with mammography. Core biopsies containing only DCIS, particularly in cases with nonspecific findings or with only Ca(++) in mammograms, represent a group of breast carcinoma that pose the high risk for incomplete resection in lumpectomy. Surgical management of patients having these cores includes wider resection margins than would otherwise be taken. Most core biopsies with only IC were associated with negative margins.