The effect of alignment of the knee on the outcome of unicompartmental knee replacement

Abstract

Many authors have recommended undercorrection of the deformity when carrying out unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA). The isolated effect of alignment of the knee on the outcome of UKA has, however, received little attention. We reviewed 185 UKAs at a minimum of five years after surgery. They had been carried out by a single surgeon using metal-backed tibial components in the management of arthritis of the medial compartment. We measured the tibiofemoral angle (TFA) before and at four months after operation and at the most recent assessment. The amount of correction of the TFA and any subsequent loss were recorded. While adjusting for the effects of age, weight and gender of the patients and the type and thickness of the implants, the mean correction was significantly less for those with a Marmor rating of failure (6.8 degrees) than for those rated excellent (9.2 degrees). The mean correction was also significantly less for patients with a Marmor rating of failure (6.8 degrees) than for those rated poor (11.1 degrees). The mean correction for the UKAs which were revised (6.6 degrees) was significantly less than for those not revised (9.1 degrees). Additionally, revised UKAs had a significantly higher percentage (63%) of thinner tibial implants (<8 mm) than the surviving UKAs (27%). These findings suggest that undercorrection of the TFA in UKA of the medial compartment should be avoided, particularly if a thin tibial polyethylene insert is used.