[Annual report of perioperative mortality and morbidity for the year 2000 at certified training hospitals of Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists: with a special reference to anesthetic methods--report of the Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists Committee on Operating Room Safety]

Abstract

The Committee on Operating Room Safety of Japan Society of Anesthesiologists (JSA) sends annually confidential questionnaires of perioperative mortality and morbidity (cardiac arrest, severe hypotension, severe hypoxia) to Certified Training Hospitals of JSA. This report is a special reference to anesthetic methods in perioperative mortality and morbidity in 2000. Five hundreds and twenty hospitals reported perioperative mortality and morbidity referred to anesthetic methods and total numbers of reported cases were 910,007. The percentage of cases reported by each anesthetic method was as follows; inhalation anesthesia 45.47%, total intravenous anesthesia (TIVA) 6.15%, inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block 24.48%, TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block 6.33%, spinal with continuous epidural block (CSEA) 3.67%, epidural anesthesia 1.92%, spinal anesthesia 10%, conduction block 0.47% and others 1.49%. The incidence of cardiac arrest per 10,000 cases due to all etiology (anesthetic management, preoperative complications, intraoperative complications, surgery, others) is estimated to be 6.55 cases in average; 5.36 cases in inhalation anesthesia, 30.72 cases in total intravenous anesthesia (TIVA), 4.62 cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 2.6 cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 1.2 cases in spinal with continuous epidural block (CSEA), 0.57 cases in epidural anesthesia, 1.65 cases in spinal anesthesia, 2.36 cases in conduction block and 46.38 cases in other methods. However, the incidence of cardiac arrest per 10,000 cases totally attributable to anesthetic management is estimated to be 0.54 cases in average; 0.34 cases in inhalation anesthesia, 1.07 cases in TIVA, 0.58 cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 0.17 cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 0.9 cases in CSEA, 0.57 cases in epidural anesthesia, 0.99 cases in spinal anesthesia, zero case in conduction block and 1.47 cases in other methods. The incidence of severe hypotension per 10,000 cases due to all etiology is estimated to be 11.14 cases in average; 11.31 cases in inhalation anesthesia, 36.61 cases in TIVA, 9.29 cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 6.59 cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 3.59 cases in CSEA, 6.3 cases in epidural anesthesia, 4.39 cases in spinal anesthesia, 2.36 cases in conduction block and 23.56 cases in other methods. On the other hand, the incidence of severe hypotension per 10,000 cases totally attributable to anesthetic management is estimated to be 1.25 cases in average; 0.97 cases in inhalation anesthesia, 0.89 cases in TIVA, 1.39 cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 1.39 cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 2.09 cases in CSEA, 3.44 cases in epidural anesthesia, 1.87 cases in spinal anesthesia, zero case in conduction block and zero case in other methods. The incidence of severe hypoxia per 10,000 cases due to all etiology is estimated to be 4.8 cases in average; 6.35 cases in inhalation anesthesia, 9.64 cases in TIVA, 3.82 cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 2.26 cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 0.3 cases in CSEA, 1.15 case in epidural anesthesia, 1.21 cases in spinal anesthesia, zero case in conduction block and 5.89 cases in other methods. On the other hands, the incidence of severe hypoxia per 10,000 cases totally attributable to anesthetic management is estimated to be 1.98 cases in average; 3.09 cases in inhalation anesthesia, 2.32 cases in TIVA, 1.3 cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 0.87 cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, zero case in CSEA, zero case in epidural anesthesia, 0.55 cases in spinal anesthesia, zero case in conduction block and zero case in other methods. The mortality rate of cardiac arrest within 7 postoperative days per 10,000 cases due to all etiology is estimated to be 3.55 (54.2%) cases in average; 3.12 (58.1%) cases in inhalation anesthesia, 19.29 (62.8%) cases in TIVA, 1.17 (25.2%) cases in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, 0.52 (20%) cases in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, zero cases in CSEA, zero case in epidural anesthesia, 0.33 (20%) cases in spinal anesthesia, zero case in conduction block and 39.76 (85.7%) cases in other methods. On the other hands, the mortality rate of cardiac arrest per 10,000 cases totally attributable to anesthesia is estimated to be 0.07 (12.2%) case in average, 0.07 (21.4%) case in inhalation anesthesia, 0.18 (16.8%) case in TIVA, zero case in inhalation anesthesia + epidural or spinal or conduction block, zero case in TIVA + epidural or spinal or conduction block, zero case in CSEA, zero case in epidural anesthesia, 0.11 (11.1%) case in spinal anesthesia, zero case in conduction block and 0.74 (50%) case in other methods. Five major combinations of listed critical incidents, causes and anesthetic methods were as follows: 18.93 cases in TIVA, preoperative complications and severe hypotension; 18.75 cases in TIVA, preoperative complications and cardiac arrest; 11.07 cases in TIVA, surgery and severe hypotension; 6.79 cases in TIVA, surgery and cardiac arrest; 5.24 cases in inhalation anesthesia, preoperative complications and severe hypotension. In summary: 1. There was no significant difference with regard to perioperative mortality and morbidity due to anesthetic management among anesthetic methods. 2. The percentage of each anesthetic method in 2000 was not different significantly from that in 1999 in spite of increased cases reported. 3. Incidence of severe hypotension due to all etiology of TIVA in 2000 decreased significantly compared with that in 1999 (P < 0.05). This may be attributed to the decreased incidence in preoperative complication (shock) and massive bleeding due to surgery.