Contribution of HPLC mass screening for neuroblastoma to a decrease in mortality

Abstract

The aim of this study is the estimation of the contribution of HPLC mass screening for neuroblastoma to the decrease in deaths due to this disease. The mortality rates of malignant neoplasms of the adrenal glands (ICD 9, 1940; ICD 10, C74; virtually all the cases of these codes are neuroblastoma during childhood) at 1-4 years of age in cohorts born in 1979-1984, 1985-1988, and 1989-1992 in the whole of Japan were calculated, using data obtained from the Ministry of Health and Welfare. The numbers of infants screened by HPLC in the cohorts were estimated through the reports of the Ministry of Health and Welfare and the database of the Japanese Society for Mass-screening. The mortality of the cohort born in 1989-1992, in which 77.8% of the live births were screened by HPLC, was 1.73 per 100,000 live births. This is about half of that (3.26) of the cohort born in 1979-1984, in which few infants were screened. On the assumption that cases of the 1985-1988 and 1989-1992 cohorts died according to the mortality rate of the 1979-1984 cohort, the expected numbers of deaths were estimated; that for the 1985-1988 cohort was 178.51 (of them, that for the infants screened by HPLC was 39.65), and that for the 1989-1992 cohort was 159.78 (of them, that for the infants screened by HPLC was 124.33). The observed numbers of deaths were 145 and 85, respectively. Assuming that non-HPLC methods have no effects and using 2 unknown quantities x (contribution of HPLC) and y (other factors), simultaneous equations (1) 178.51 - 39.65x - 178.51y = 145 and (2) 159.78 - 124.33x - 159.78y = 85 were made. Solving them, x = 0.5041 and y = 0.0757 were obtained. In conclusion HPLC screening targeting infants aged 6 months reduces death of adrenal neuroblastomas at 1-4 years of age by about 50%.