The use of MRI scan of knee injuries in an emergency department

Abstract

We present a retrospective study of the number of arthroscopically verified total meniscus and cruciate ligament tears seen in our Emergency department one year before, and one year after introducing magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) as a diagnostic tool. The number of total ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament increased from 34 (1.7% of total 2003 patients) to 67 (2.9% of total 2277). The number of ruptures of the medial meniscus increased from 42 (2.1%) to 87 (3.8%). The number of ruptures of the lateral meniscus remained unchanged. In the first 12 months after introducing MRI we ordered 513 (23%) scans of the total number of 2277 patients with an acute knee condition. Thirty-nine (8%) of these were described with no pathology, 227 (44%) showed total meniscus or cruciate ligament tears. The remaining 247 (48%) were mainly degenerative or partial injuries. The cost per additional new diagnosis was approximately USD 800. The introduction of MRI has enabled us to identify a larger number of patients with meniscus and cruciate ligament injuries.