Theoretical and experimental quantification of carotid plaque volume measurements made by three-dimensional ultrasound using test phantoms

Abstract

An accurate technique that exhibits low variability has practical importance for the quantification of carotid plaque volume. Such a technique is necessary to monitor plaque progression or regression that may result in response to nonsurgical therapy. In this study, we investigate the accuracy and variability of plaque volume measurement by three-dimensional ultrasound using vascular plaque phantoms over a range of 68.2 mm3 to 285.5 mm3. The agar plaques maintained a consistent cylindrical geometry with variations in the height, length, and echogenicity. The volume of each plaque was determined by water displacement. The three-dimensional (3D) ultrasound (US) images were acquired with a mechanical scanning system which creates a 3D US Cartesian volume, that was manipulated and viewed in any orientation, from a collection of conventional parallel two-dimensional (2D) US images. The plaque volumes were measured by serial 2D manual planimtery. The mean accuracy in plaque volume measurement was 3.1+/-0.9%. Variability in plaque volume measurement was calculated to be 4.0+/-1.0% and 5.1+/-1.4% for intraobserver and interobserver measurements, respectively. We have also developed a theoretical description for the variance in measurement of plaque volume using manual planimetry. Root-mean-square difference between experimentally and theoretically determined values of plaque volume fractional variance was 9%.