Enrichment and elimination of mutY mutators in Escherichia coli populations

Abstract

The kinetics of mutator sweeps was followed in two independent populations of Escherichia coli grown for up to 350 generations in glucose-limited continuous culture. A rapid elevation of mutation rates was observed in both populations within 120-150 generations, as was apparent from major increases in the proportion of the populations with unselected mutations in fhuA. The increase in mutation rates was due to sweeps by mutY mutators. In both cultures, the enrichment of mutators resulted from hitchhiking with identified beneficial mutations increasing fitness under glucose limitation; mutY hitchhiked with mgl mutations in one culture and ptsG in the other. In both cases, mutators were enriched to constitute close to 100% of the population before a periodic selection event reduced the frequency of unselected mutations and mutators in the cultures. The high proportion of mutators persisted for 150 generations in one population but began to be eliminated within 50 generations in the other. The persistence of mutator, as well as experimental data showing that mutY bacteria were as fit as near-isogenic mutY(+) bacteria in competition experiments, suggest that mutator load by deleterious mutations did not explain the rapidly diminishing proportion of mutators in the populations. The nonmutators sweeping out mutators were also unlikely to have arisen by reversion or antimutator mutations; the mutY mutations were major deletions in each case and the bacteria sweeping out mutators contained intact mutY. By following mgl allele frequencies in one population, we discovered that mutators were outcompeted by bacteria that had rare mgl mutations previously as well as additional beneficial mutation(s). The pattern of appearance of mutY, but not its elimination, conforms to current models of mutator sweeps in bacterial populations. A mutator with a narrow mutational spectrum like mutY may be lost if the requirement for beneficial mutations is for changes other than GC --> TA transversions. Alternatively, epistatic interactions between mutator mutation and beneficial mutations need to be postulated to explain mutator elimination.