Estimation of tumor growth fractions in archival formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues using two anti-PCNA/Cyclin monoclonal antibodies. Factors affecting reactivity

Abstract

Immunohistochemical detection of cell cycle-related markers for estimation of tumor growth fractions using paraffin-embedded tissue sections would have applications in experimental and clinical pathology as an in situ histologic alternative to flow cytometry. The monoclonal antibodies 19A2 and PC10 detect the proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA/Cyclin), an auxiliary protein to DNA polymerase-delta. In a prospective group of uniformly handled, formalin-fixed malignant lymphomas we previously demonstrated 19A2 to be a reliable marker of proliferative activity similar to Ki-67 in frozen tissue. The present study examines the applicability of this technique in archival formalin-fixed material. Studies on tonsilar tissue revealed that formalin fixation beyond 30 hours adversely affected reactivity of 19A2, possibly explaining the variable results in nonuniformly fixed archival material. We found that only 27 (56%) of 48 archival cases of infiltrating ductal carcinoma showed sufficient reactivity with 19A2 to permit reliable quantification of the tumor growth fraction. Acid pretreatment with 2N HCl had no apparent effect on 19A2 reactivity. Using both antibodies on a group of 32 archival lymphomas, carcinomas, and sarcomas, significantly more biopsies stained reliably for PC10 (84%) than for 19A2 (72%; P < 0.036). Further, none of the cases that did not react with PC10 reacted with 19A2. PC10 may recognize a different epitope of PCNA/Cyclin which may be more resistant to alterations by fixation. In the 23 cases that reliably stained for both markers, largely carcinomas, there was excellent correlation between estimated growth fractions (r = 0.96). Although immunostaining provides a useful way to estimate tumor growth fractions in paraffin-embedded tissues, modifications of technique and cautious interpretation of results are advisable when using archival material.