Immunohistochemical and ultrastructural correlates of muscle-actin expression in pleomorphic adenomas and myoepitheliomas based on comparison of formalin and methanol fixation

Abstract

The degree and range of differentiation of the cells referred to as myoepithelial-like in pleomorphic adenomas and the tumour cells of myoepitheliomas are not definitely established. This type of information is critical for establishing reliable diagnostic criteria, such as expression of muscle-specific actin and ultrastructural identification of myofilaments, in these and other salivary gland tumours. Pleomorphic adenomas (18) and myoepitheliomas (5), of which 10 cases were fixed only in formalin and 13 cases where tissues were fixed in both formalin and methanol/acetic acid, were studied. Each tumour and normal accompanying parotid was immunostained with two monoclonal antibodies for smooth muscle actin, HHF35 and MSA. Staining of myoepithelial cells was absent in certain samples of normal gland with both HHF35 (15%) and MSA (69%) when formalin-fixed tissue was used. Using formalin-fixed tissue from 15 pleomorphic adenomas/myoepitheliomas, 2 (14%) had focal positivity with HHF35, while 8 cases (57%) were positive with MSA. However, a certain degree of false positivity was suspected since in samples of normal parotid, both acinar and duct cells were frequently stained, particularly with MSA. With methanol/acetic acid-fixed tissue only 4 of 13 cases (31%) were positive with either MSA or HHF35 and 2 of these only had a minor proportion of the tumour cells expressing muscle-specific actin. Using alcohol-fixed tissue, myoepithelial cells were strongly stained in all examples of normal parotid gland with both anti-actin antibodies. In 5 cases examined by electron microscopy, there was no apparent correlation between immunohistochemical results and the presence or absence of cytoplasmic filament accumulation. The results indicate considerable tumour cell heterogeneity in muscle-specific actin expression and suggest that non-luminal cells in pleomorphic adenomas and the tumour cells in myoepitheliomas may differentiate as classical myoepithelial cells, as partially differentiated (i.e. modified myoepithelial cells) or as the counterpart of basal cells present in the intra- and interlobular ducts of normal salivary gland.