Biomechanical analysis of the mechanism of interlocking nail failure

Abstract

From December 1986 to May 1989, 412 patients with 274 femoral and 144 tibial fractures were treated with Grosse-Kempf interlocking nails at our hospital. 324 cases (78.6%) were followed-up for at least 1 year (average 23 months). There were 13 breakages in the locking nails in femora and none in tibiae. The recorded incidence of breakage in the femur is therefore 4.7% (13/274). The mechanisms of locking nail failure are stress concentration around screw hole and nail slot, nicking of the nail during drilling of the screw holes, too close proximity of the screw hole to the fracture, and larger loading over the proximal femur. The incidence of failure is 4.9% in the upper third, 1.9% in the mid-third, and 8.2% in the distal third (P greater than 0.05, chi 2 test). The site most at risk is the first screw hole of the distal third, especially if it is near the fracture site. Prevention of failure involves using a nail of larger diameter and sufficient length, improving the surgical drilling technique, and allowing only protected weight bearing. Management of nail breakage by insertion of a new implant and supplementary cancellous bone grafting can gain satisfactory results.