Radiosensitivity testing of human malignant gliomas

Abstract

Radiotherapy remains the main treatment modality for patients with malignant gliomas and is the only treatment which significantly prolongs survival. Clonogenic and tetrazolium based colorimetric assays (MTT) of early passage cultures have been performed following 2 Gy doses of x-rays in order to determine if in vitro radiosensitivity is a factor in response to treatment. Of 47 biopsies received, 39 were established in primary culture. A value of surviving fraction to 2 Gy (SF2) was obtained in 85% of growth assays and 64% of clonogenic assays. The mean SF2 value for the MTT was 0.56 which was significantly higher than the 0.42 obtained for the clonogenic assay. There was, however, reasonable qualitative agreement in assessing relative radiosensitivity/radioresistance (r = 0.7). Mean SF2 values for grade 3 tumors were 0.52 (MTT) and 0.35 (clonogenic) as against mean SF2 values of 0.63 (MTT) and 0.47 (clonogenic assay) for grade 4 tumors. In 24 patients with adequate follow-up, no direct correlation was found between SF2 and survival, although mean SF2 values for patients surviving greater than 18 months was significantly less (p = 0.01) than patients surviving less than 18 months as determined by the MTT assay.