A reassessment of histologic classification and an immunohistochemical study of 88 retinoblastomas. A special reference to the advent of bipolar-like cells

Abstract

Background: Despite perpetual efforts of investigators, the histogenesis of retinoblastoma is still in dispute and histologic classification satisfactorily predictive of prognosis does not seem to be in use.

Methods: The authors studied 88 cases of retinoblastoma clinicopathologically and immunohistochemically, paying special attention to the presence of a "bipolar-like cell" element that would be used as one of the criteria for the diagnosis of differentiated retinoblastoma.

Results: Twelve cases of retinoblastoma with the bipolar-like cell element in the absence of rosettes and 41 cases of the tumor with rosettes were classified as differentiated retinoblastomas. The other 35 cases without rosettes or bipolar-like cells were classified as undifferentiated tumors. Tumor cells forming rosettes usually had positive results for synaptophysin and neuron-specific enolase (NSE) and negative results for glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) and S-100 protein; however, undifferentiated cells had negative results for these four antibodies. The bipolar-like cells had positive results for synaptophysin and NSE but negative results for GFAP and S-100 protein. Twelve tumors with bipolar-like cells that lacked rosettes showed no optic nerve invasion, and the patients had a significantly better prognosis (100% 5-year survival rate) than 35 patients with undifferentiated tumors (71% 5-year survival rate) (P < 0.01).

Conclusions: The findings support a neuronal origin of the tumor and indicate that, not only the rosettes symbolizing the photoreceptor differentiation, but also other neuronal elements, such as bipolar-like cells, can be used as criteria for histologic classification of retinoblastoma.