Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
Meta-Analysis
. 2004;2004(1):CD002780.
doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002780.pub2.

One topical fluoride (toothpastes, or mouthrinses, or gels, or varnishes) versus another for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents

V C C Marinho  1 , J P T Higgins, A Sheiham, S Logan
Affiliations
Meta-Analysis

One topical fluoride (toothpastes, or mouthrinses, or gels, or varnishes) versus another for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents

V C C Marinho et al. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2004.

Abstract

Background: Topical fluorides in the form of toothpaste, mouthrinse, varnish and gel are effective caries preventive measures. However, there is uncertainty about the relative value of these interventions.

Objectives: To compare the effectiveness of one form of topical fluoride intervention with another when used for the prevention of dental caries in children.

Search strategy: We searched the Cochrane Oral Health Group's Trials Register (May 2000), the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) (The Cochrane Library Issue 2, 2000), MEDLINE (1966 to January 2000), plus several other databases. We handsearched journals, reference lists of articles and contacted selected authors and manufacturers.

Selection criteria: Randomized or quasi-randomized controlled trials with blind outcome assessment, comparing fluoride varnish, gel, mouthrinse, or toothpaste with each other in children up to 16 years during at least 1 year. The main outcome was caries increment measured by the change in decayed, missing and filled tooth surfaces (D(M)FS).

Data collection and analysis: Inclusion decisions, quality assessment and data extraction were duplicated in a random sample of one third of studies, and consensus achieved by discussion or a third party. Authors were contacted for missing data. The primary measure of effect was the prevented fraction (PF) that is the difference in mean caries increments between the 'experimental' and 'control' groups expressed as a percentage of the mean increment in the control group. Random effects meta-analyses were performed where data could be pooled.

Main results: There were 17 studies included, and 15 contributed data for the meta-analyses. Fluoride toothpaste was not significantly different from mouthrinse (pooled DMFS PF 0%; 95% CI, -18% to 19%; p = 0.94), or gel (pooled DMFS PF 0%; 95% CI, -21% to 21%; p = 1), or both gel and mouthrinse (pooled DMFS PF 1%; 95% CI, -13% to 14%; p = 0.94); heterogeneity was substantial. Results from the single trial comparing toothpaste with varnish (in deciduous teeth) were inconclusive (dfs PF 5%; CI not obtainable). The pooled results from the comparisons of fluoride varnish with mouthrinse was a non-significant difference favouring varnish (DMFS PF 10%; 95% CI, -12% to 32%; p = 0.40), but this result was not robust to sensitivity analysis performed, and heterogeneity was considerable. Results from the single trial comparing varnish with gel (14%, 95% CI, -12% to 40%; p = 0.30) and the single trial comparing gel with mouthrinse (-14% DMFS PF; 95% CI, -40% to 12%; p = 0.30) were inconclusive (favoured varnish and mouthrinse respectively).

Reviewer's conclusions: Fluoride toothpastes in comparison to mouthrinses or gels appear to have a similar degree of effectiveness for the prevention of dental caries in children. There is no clear suggestion that fluoride varnish is more effective than mouthrinses and the evidence for the comparative effectiveness of fluoride varnishes and gels, and mouthrinses and gels is inconclusive. No conclusions about adverse effects could be reached, because no data were reported on in the trials. Acceptance is likely to be greater for fluoride toothpaste.

PubMed Disclaimer

Conflict of interest statement

None known.

Figures

1.1
1.1. Analysis
Comparison 1 Fluoride varnish versus Fluoride gel, Outcome 1 D(M)FS increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (1 trial).
2.1
2.1. Analysis
Comparison 2 Fluoride varnish versus Fluoride mouthrinse, Outcome 1 D(M)FS increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (4 trials).
2.2
2.2. Analysis
Comparison 2 Fluoride varnish versus Fluoride mouthrinse, Outcome 2 Unacceptability of treatment as measured by leaving study early (2 trials).
3.1
3.1. Analysis
Comparison 3 Fluoride varnish versus Fluoride toothpaste, Outcome 1 d(e)fs increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (1 trial).
3.2
3.2. Analysis
Comparison 3 Fluoride varnish versus Fluoride toothpaste, Outcome 2 Unacceptability of treatment as measured by leaving study early (1 trials).
4.1
4.1. Analysis
Comparison 4 Fluoride toothpaste versus Fluoride gel, Outcome 1 D(M)FS increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (3 trials).
5.1
5.1. Analysis
Comparison 5 Fluoride toothpaste versus Fluoride mouthrinse, Outcome 1 D(M)FS increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (6 trials).
5.2
5.2. Analysis
Comparison 5 Fluoride toothpaste versus Fluoride mouthrinse, Outcome 2 Unacceptability of treatment as measured by leaving study early (5 trials).
6.1
6.1. Analysis
Comparison 6 Fluoride gel versus Fluoride mouthrinse, Outcome 1 D(M)FS increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (1 trial).
7.1
7.1. Analysis
Comparison 7 Fluoride toothpaste versus Other topical fluoride, Outcome 1 D(M)FS increment (PF) ‐ nearest to 3 years (9 trials).
7.2
7.2. Analysis
Comparison 7 Fluoride toothpaste versus Other topical fluoride, Outcome 2 Unacceptability of treatment as measured by leaving study early (6 trials).
See this image and copyright information in PMC

Update of

References

References to studies included in this review

Ashley 1977 {published data only}
    1. Ashley FP, Mainwaring PJ, Emslie RD, Naylor MN. Clinical testing of a mouthrinse and a dentifrice containing fluoride. A two‐year supervised study in school children. British Dental Journal 1977;143:333‐8. - PubMed
Axelsson 1987 {published data only}
    1. Axelsson P, Paulander J, Nordkvist K, Karlsson R. Effect of fluoride containing dentifrice, mouthrinsing, and varnish on approximal dental caries in a 3‐year clinical trial. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 1987;15:177‐80. - PubMed
Blinkhorn 1983 {published and unpublished data}
    1. Blinkhorn AS, Holloway PJ, Davies TG. Combined effects of a fluoride dentifrice and mouthrinse on the incidence of dental caries. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 1983;11:7‐11. - PubMed
Bruun 1985 {published data only}
    1. Bruun C, Bille J, Hansen KT, Kann J, Qvist V, Thylstrup A. Three‐year caries increments after fluoride rinses or topical applications with a fluoride varnish. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 1985;13:299‐303. - PubMed
DePaola 1980 {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
    1. DePaola PF, Soparkar M, Leeuwen M, DeVelis R. The anticaries effect of single and combined topical fluoride systems in school children. Archives of Oral Biology 1980;25:649‐53. - PubMed
    1. Lu KH, Porter DR, Pickles TH. Separate and combined cariostatic effects of fluoride gel and rinse [abstract No 239]. Journal of Dental Research 1980;59:947.
Kirkegaard 1986 {published data only}
    1. Kirkegaard E, Petersen G, Poulsen S, Holm SA, Heidmann J. Caries‐preventive effect of Duraphat varnish applications versus fluoride mouthrinses: 5‐year data. Caries Research 1986;20:548‐55. - PubMed
Koch 1967 {published data only}
    1. Hollender L, Koch G. Influence of topical application of fluoride on rate of progress of carious lesions in children. A long‐term roentgenographic follow‐up. Odontologisk Revy 1969;20:37‐41. - PubMed
    1. Koch G. Effect of sodium fluoride in dentifrice and mouthwash on incidence of dental caries in school‐children. Odontologisk Revy 1967;18(Suppl. 12):1‐125.
    1. Koch G, Lindhe J. The effect of supervised oral hygiene on the gingiva of children. The effect of sodium fluoride. Journal of Periodontal Research 1967;2:64‐9. - PubMed
    1. Koch G, Lindhe J. The state of the gingivae and the caries‐increment in school‐children during and after withdrawal of various prophylactic measures. In: McHugh WD editor(s). Dental Plaque. A symposium held at the University of Dundee, 22 to 24 September, 1969. Edinburgh and London: E. & S. Livingstone, 1970:271‐81.
Koch 1979 {published data only}
    1. Koch G, Petersson LG, Ryden H. Effect of flouride varnish (Duraphat) treatment every six months compared with weekly mouthrinses with 0.2 per cent NaF solution on dental caries. Swedish Dental Journal 1979;3:39‐44. - PubMed
Mainwaring 1978 {published data only}
    1. Mainwaring PJ, Naylor MN. A three‐year clinical study to determine the separate and combined caries‐inhibiting effects of sodium monofluorophosphate toothpaste and an acidulated phosphate‐fluoride gel. Caries Research 1978;12:202‐12. - PubMed
Marthaler 1970 {published data only}
    1. Marthaler TM, Konig KG, Muhlemann HR. The effect of a fluoride gel used for supervised toothbrushing 15 or 30 times per year. Helvetica Odontologica Acta 1970;14:67‐77. - PubMed
Marthaler 1970a {published data only}
    1. Marthaler TM, Konig KG, Muhlemann HR. The effect of a fluoride gel used for supervised toothbrushing 15 or 30 times per year. Helvetica Odontologica Acta 1970;14:67‐77. - PubMed
Petersson 1985 {published data only}
    1. Petersson LG, Koch G, Rasmusson CG, Stanke H. Effect on caries of different fluoride prophylactic programs in preschool children. A two year clinical study. Swedish Dental Journal 1985;9:97‐104. - PubMed
Ran 1991 {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
    1. Ran F, Gedalia I, Fried M, Hadani P, Tved A. Effectiveness of fortnightly tooth brushing with amine fluorides in caries‐prone subjects. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 1991;18:311‐6. - PubMed
Ringelberg 1979 {published data only}
    1. Ringelberg ML, Webster DB. Effects of an amine fluoride mouthrinse and dentifrice on the gingival health and the extent of plaque of school children. Journal of Periodontology 1977;48:350‐3. - PubMed
    1. Ringelberg ML, Webster DB, Dixon DO. Effects of an amine fluoride dentifrice and mouthrinse on the dental caries of school children after 18 months. Journal of Preventive Dentistry 1978;5:26‐30. - PubMed
    1. Ringelberg ML, Webster DB, Dixon DO, Fairchild S, Driscoll WS. Results of gingival, plaque, and stain assessments after 30 months use of amine fluorides and their inorganic counterparts. Pharmacology and Therapeutics in Dentistry 1979;4:27‐31. - PubMed
    1. Ringelberg ML, Webster DB, Dixon DO, LeZotte DC. The caries‐preventive effect of amine fluorides and inorganic fluorides in a mouthrinse or dentifrice after 30 months of use. Journal of the American Dental Association 1979;98:202‐8. - PubMed
Seppa 1987 {published data only}
    1. Seppa L, Pollanen L. Caries preventive effect of two fluoride varnishes and a fluoride mouthrinse. Caries Research 1987;21:375‐9. - PubMed
Seppa 1995 {published data only}
    1. Seppa L, Leppanen T, Hausen H. Fluoride varnish versus acidulated phosphate fluoride gel: a 3‐year clinical trial. Caries Research 1995;29:327‐30. - PubMed
Torell 1965 {published data only}
    1. Torell P. The Goteborg studies of methods of applying fluorides topically. In: Hardwick JL, Held HR, Konig KG editor(s). Advances in fluorine research and dental caries prevention. Vol. 3, Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1965:255‐8. - PubMed
    1. Torell P, Ericsson Y. Two year clinical tests with different methods of local caries‐preventive fluorine application in Swedish school‐children (Part I: The Goteborg study). Acta Odontologica Scandinavica 1965;23:287‐312. - PubMed

References to studies excluded from this review

Barnaud 1984 {published data only}
    1. Barnaud J, Finidori C. The preventive effectiveness of a toothpaste with a high fluoride content [Etude de l'efficacite preventive d'une pate a haute teneur en fluorures]. Journal of the International Association of Dentistry for Children 1984;15:21‐31. - PubMed
    1. Barnaud J, Finidori C, Texier T, Suen A. Dentifrice pastes with high fluoride contents [Les pates dentifrices a hautes teneurs en fluor]. Chirurgien Dentiste de France 1984;54:50‐1. - PubMed
Hamp 1984 {published data only}
    1. Hamp SE, Johansson LA, Karlsson R. Clinical effects of preventive regimens for young people in their early and middle teens in relation to previous experience with dental prevention. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica 1984;42:99‐108. - PubMed
Ivanova 1990 {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
    1. Ivanova EN. The comparative efficacy of local anticaries agents [Sravnitel'naia effektivnost' mestnykh protivokarioznykh sredtsv]. Stomatologiia Moskva 1990;69:60‐1. - PubMed
Ivanova 1990a {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
    1. Ivanova EN, Frolova GI, Postoiuk SN, Liakh GA. The status of the oral cavity and results of the use of fluorine‐containing preparations in preventing dental caries in children [Sostoianie polosti rta i rezul'taty primeneniia ftorsoderzhashchikh preparatov v profilaktike kariesa zubov u detei]. Stomatologiia Moskva 1990;69:69‐70. - PubMed
Karjalainen 1994 {published data only}
    1. Karjalainen S, Eriksson AL, Ruokola M, Toivonen A. Caries development after substitution of supervised fluoride rinses and toothbrushings by unsupervised use of fluoride toothpaste. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 1994;22:421‐4. - PubMed
Ramos 1995 {published data only}
    1. Ramos SB. Efeito de bochechos fluoretados (NaF ‐ 0,2 por cento) e da aplicacao do verniz com fluor (NaF ‐ 5 por cento) na prevencao da carie dentaria: estudo comparativo em escolares da Regiao Norte da cidade de Sao Paulo, 1992‐1993 [Effect of fortnightly rinsing with a 0.2 percent NaF solution and a fluoride varnish with 5 percent NaF in dental caries prevention: comparative study in students of the northern region of Sao Paulo city, Brazil, 1992‐ 1993] [dissertation]. Sao Paulo: Universidade de Sao Paulo (SP), 1995.
Shobha 1987 {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
    1. Shobha T, Nandlal B, Prabhakar AR, Sudha P. Fluoride varnish versus acidulated phosphate fluoride for schoolchildren in Manipal. Journal of the Indian Dental Association 1987;59:157‐60. - PubMed
Suntsov 1991 {published data only}
    1. Suntsov VG, Distel' VA, Zhorova TN, Buiankina RG, Toropov VN, Bulanova EL. The trace efficacy of dental caries prevention in children [Sledovaia effektivnost' profilaktiki kariesa zubov u detei]. Stomatologiia Moskva 1991;2(2):69‐71. - PubMed
Wilson 1978 {published data only (unpublished sought but not used)}
    1. Wilson CJ, Triol CW, Volpe AR. The clinical anticaries effect of a fluoride dentifrice and mouthrinse [abstract]. Journal of Dental Research 1978;57:276.

References to studies awaiting assessment

Autio 1999 {published data only}
    1. Autio J, Courts F. Feasibility of a fluoride varnish program in Head Start Children [abstract]. Journal of Dental Research 1999;78:170.
Cichocka 1981 {published data only}
    1. Cichocka E. Economic evaluation of selected methods of contact fluoridation of the teeth [Ocena ekonomiczna wybranych metod kontaktowego fluorkowania zebow]. Czasopismo Stomatologiczne 1981;34:245‐50. - PubMed
    1. Cichocka E. Oral hygiene and the efficacy of selected methods of contact tooth fluoridation [Higiena jamy ustnej a skutecznosc wybranych metod kontaktowego fluorkowania zebow]. Czasopismo Stomatologiczne 1981;34:145‐53. - PubMed

Additional references

Burt 1998
    1. Burt BA. Prevention policies in the light of the changed distribution of dental caries. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica 1998;56:179‐86. - PubMed
Chen 1995
    1. Chen MS. Oral health of disadvantaged populations. In: Cohen LK, Gift CH editor(s). Disease Prevention and Oral Health Promotion. Copenhagen: Munksgaard, 1995:152‐212.
Clarke 2000
    1. Clarke M, Oxman AD (editors). Assessment of study quality. Cochrane Reviewers' Handbook version 4.1 [updated June 2000]; Section 6. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2000.
Downer 1995
    1. Downer MC. The 1993 national survey of children's dental health. British Dental Journal 1995;178:407‐12. - PubMed
Dubey 1965
    1. Dubey SD, Lehnhoff RW, Radike AW. A statistical confidence interval for true per cent reduction in caries‐incidence studies. Journal of Dental Research 1965;44:921‐3. - PubMed
Egger 1997
    1. Egger M, Davey‐Smith G, Schneider M, Minder C. Bias in meta‐analysis detected by a simple graphical test. BMJ 1997;315(7109):629‐34. - PMC - PubMed
Featherstone 1988
    1. Featherstone JDB, Cate JM. Physicochemical aspects of fluoride‐enamel interactions. In: Ekstrand J, Fejerskov O, Silverstone LM editor(s). Fluoride in Dentistry. Copenhagen: Munksgaard, 1988:125‐49.
Glass 1982
    1. Glass RL. The first international conference on the declining prevalence of dental caries. Journal of Dental Research 1982;61:1301‐83.
Higgins 1996
    1. Higgins JP, Whitehead A. Borrowing strength from external trials in a meta‐analysis. Statistics in Medicine 1996;15:2733‐49. - PubMed
Higgins 2003
    1. Higgins J. Personal communication August 4 2003.
Marinho 1997
    1. Marinho VC. A systematic review of the effectiveness of topical fluoride therapy in the prevention of dental caries in children and adolescents [dissertation]. London: University of London 1997.
Marinho 2002
    1. Marinho VCC, Higgins J, Logan S, Sheiham A. Fluoride gels for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2002, Issue 2. [Art. No.: CD002280. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD002280] - PubMed
Marinho 2002a
    1. Marinho VCC, Higgins J, Logan S, Sheiham A. Fluoride varnishes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2002, Issue 3. [Art. No.: CD002279. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD002279] - PubMed
Marinho 2003
    1. Marinho VCC, Higgins J, Sheiham A, Logan S. Fluoride toothpastes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2003, Issue 1. [Art. No.: CD002278. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD002278] - PMC - PubMed
Marinho 2003a
    1. Marinho VCC, Higgins J, Logan S, Sheiham A. Fluoride mouthrinses for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2003, Issue 3. [Art. No.: CD002284. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD002284] - PubMed
Marinho 2003b
    1. Marinho VCC, Higgins J, Logan S, Sheiham A. Topical fluoride (toothpastes, mouthrinses, gels or varnishes) for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2003, Issue 4. [Art. No.: CD002782. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD002782] - PMC - PubMed
Marthaler 1994
    1. Marthaler TM, Steiner M, Menghini G, Bandi A. Caries prevalence in Switzerland. International Dental Journal 1994;44:393‐401. - PubMed
Marthaler 1996
    1. Marthaler TM, O'Mullane DM, Vrbic V. The prevalence of dental caries in Europe 1990‐1995. ORCA Saturday afternoon symposium 1995. Caries Research 1996;30:237‐55. - PubMed
Moynihan 1996
    1. Moynihan PJ, Holt RD. The national diet and nutrition survey of 1.5 to 4.5 year old children: summary of the findings of the dental survey. British Dental Journal 1996;181:328‐32. - PubMed
Murray 1991
    1. Murray JJ, Rugg‐Gunn AJ, Jenkins GN. A history of water fluoridation. In: Murray JJ, Rugg‐Gunn AJ, Jenkins GN editor(s). Fluorides in caries prevention. Oxford: Wright, 1991:7‐37.
Murray 1991a
    1. Murray JJ, Rugg‐Gunn AJ, Jenkins GN. Fluoride toothpastes and dental caries. In: Murray JJ, Rugg‐Gunn AJ, Jenkins GN editor(s). Fluorides in caries prevention. Oxford: Wright, 1991:127‐60.
O'Mullane 1995
    1. O'Mullane DM. Contribution of fluoride toothpastes to oral health. In: Bowen WH editor(s). Relative efficacy of sodium fluoride and sodium monofluorophosphate as anti‐caries agents in dentifrices. The Royal Society Of Medicine Press Limited, 1995:3‐7.
Pitts 2001
    1. Pitts NB, Evans DJ, Nugent ZJ. The dental caries experience of 5‐year‐old children in Great Britain. Surveys coordinated by the British Association for the Study of Community Dentistry in 1999/2000. Community Dental Health 2001;18(1):49‐55. - PubMed
Pitts 2002
    1. Pitts NB, Evans DJ, Nugent ZJ, Pine CM. The dental caries experience of 12‐year‐old children in England and Wales. Surveys coordinated by the British Association for the Study of Community Dentistry in 2000/2001. Community Dental Health 2002;19(1):46‐53. - PubMed
Ripa 1991
    1. Ripa LW. A critique of topical fluoride methods (dentifrices, mouthrinses, operator‐applied, and self‐applied gels) in an era of decreased caries and increased fluorosis prevalence. Journal Of Public Health Dentistry 1991;1:23‐41. - PubMed
Rolla 1991
    1. Rolla G, Ogaard B, Cruz R‐d‐A. Clinical effect and mechanism of cariostatic action of fluoride‐containing toothpastes: a review. International Dental Journal 1991;41:171‐4. - PubMed
Seppa 1998
    1. Seppa L, Karkkainen S, Hausen H. Caries frequency in permanent teeth before and after discontinuation of water fluoridation in Kuopio, Finland. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 1998;26:256‐62. - PubMed
Sharp 1998
    1. Sharp S. Meta‐analysis regression: statistics, biostatistics, and epidemiology 23 (sbe23). Stata Technical Bulletin 1998; Vol. 42:16‐22.
Song 2003
    1. Song F, Altman DG, Glenny A‐M, Deeks JJ. Validity of indirect comparison for estimating efficacy of competing interventions: empirical evidence from published meta‐analyses. BMJ 2003;326(7387):472. - PMC - PubMed
Strohmenger 2001
    1. Strohmenger L, Brambilla E. The use of fluoride varnishes in the prevention of dental caries: a short review. Oral Diseases 2001;7:71‐80. - PubMed
Thompson 1999
    1. Thompson SG, Sharp SJ. Explaining heterogeneity in meta‐analysis: a comparison of methods. Statistics in Medicine 1999;18(20):2693‐708. - PubMed
van Rijkom 1998
    1. Rijkom HM, Truin GJ, 't Hof MA. A meta‐analysis of clinical studies on the caries‐inhibiting effect of fluoride gel treatment. Caries Research 1998;32:83‐92. - PubMed