Skip to main page content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Dot gov

The .gov means it’s official.
Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. Before sharing sensitive information, make sure you’re on a federal government site.

Https

The site is secure.
The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the official website and that any information you provide is encrypted and transmitted securely.

Access keys NCBI Homepage MyNCBI Homepage Main Content Main Navigation
Comparative Study
. 2004;2004(1):CD004325.
doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004325.pub2.

Surgical versus non-surgical treatment for acute anterior shoulder dislocation

H H G Handoll, M A Almaiyah, A Rangan
Comparative Study

Surgical versus non-surgical treatment for acute anterior shoulder dislocation

H H G Handoll et al. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2004.

Abstract

Background: Acute anterior shoulder dislocation is the commonest type of shoulder dislocation. Subsequently, the shoulder is less stable and more susceptible to re-dislocation, especially in active young adults.

Objectives: We aimed to compare surgical versus non-surgical treatment for acute anterior dislocation of the shoulder.

Search strategy: We searched the Cochrane Musculoskeletal Injuries Group specialised register (August 2003), the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (The Cochrane Library Issue 3, 2003), MEDLINE (1966 to September week 3 2003), EMBASE (1988 to 2003 week 39), the National Research Register (UK) (Issue 3, 2003), conference proceedings and reference lists of articles.

Selection criteria: Randomised or quasi-randomised controlled trials comparing surgical with conservative interventions for treating acute anterior shoulder dislocation.

Data collection and analysis: Selection of the included trials was by all three reviewers. Two reviewers independently assessed methodological quality and extracted data. Where appropriate, results of comparable studies were pooled.

Main results: Five studies were included. These involved a total of 239 young (mainly aged around 22 years) active and mainly male people, all of whom had had a primary (first time) traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation. Methodological quality was variable, but notably there was insufficient information to judge whether allocation was effectively concealed in all five trials. Two trials, involving 115 participants, were only reported in conference abstracts.One trial involving military personnel reported that all had returned to active duty. Another trial reported similar numbers in the two intervention groups with reduced sports participation, and a third trial reported that significantly fewer people in the surgical group failed to attain previous levels of sports activity. Pooled results from all five trials showed that subsequent instability, either redislocation or subluxation, was statistically significantly less frequent in the surgical group (relative risk (RR) 0.20; 95%confidence interval (CI) 0.11 to 0.33). This result remained statistically significant (RR 0.32, 95%CI 0.17 to 0.59) for the three trials reported in full. Half (17/33) of the conservatively treated patients with shoulder instability in these three trials opted for subsequent surgery.Different, mainly patient-rated, functional assessment measures for the shoulder were recorded in the five trials. The results were more favourable, usually statistically significantly so, in the surgically treated group. Aside from a septic joint in a surgically treated patient, there were no other treatment complications reported. There was no information on shoulder pain, long-term complications such as osteoarthritis or on service utilisation and resource use.

Reviewer's conclusions: The limited evidence available supports primary surgery for young adults, usually male, engaged in highly demanding physical activities who have sustained their first acute traumatic shoulder dislocation. There is no evidence available to determine whether non-surgical treatment should not remain the prime treatment option for other categories of patient. Sufficiently powered, good quality and adequately reported randomised trials of good standard surgical treatment versus good standard conservative treatment for well-defined injuries are required; in particular, for patient categories at lower risk of activity-limiting recurrence. Long term surveillance of outcome, looking at shoulder disorders including osteoarthritis is also required. Reviews comparing different surgical interventions and different conservative interventions including rehabilitation are needed.

PubMed Disclaimer

Conflict of interest statement

None known.

Figures

1.1
1.1. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 1 Non return to pre‐injury level of activity.
1.2
1.2. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 2 Instability: redislocation or subluxation.
1.3
1.3. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 3 Instability: redislocation or subluxation (minus 1 trial).
1.4
1.4. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 4 Subsequent surgery for instability.
1.5
1.5. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 5 WOSI (Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index) scores at 32 months.
1.6
1.6. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 6 WOSI (Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index) scores at 79 months.
1.7
1.7. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 7 Rowe shoulder score: fair or poor score.
1.8
1.8. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 8 Objective instability: positive apprehension test.
1.9
1.9. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 9 Range of movement: % of normal side.
1.10
1.10. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 10 Treatment complications.
1.11
1.11. Analysis
Comparison 1 Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment, Outcome 11 Patient dissatisfaction.
See this image and copyright information in PMC

Update of

  • doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004325

Similar articles

See all similar articles

Cited by

See all "Cited by" articles

References

References to studies included in this review

Bottoni 2002 {published data only}
    1. Bottoni CR, Wilckens JH, DeBerardino TM, D'Alleyrand JG, Rooney RC, Harpstrite JK, et al. A prospective, randomized evaluation of arthroscopic stabilization versus nonoperative treatment in patients with acute, traumatic, first‐time shoulder dislocations. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2002;30(4):576‐80. - PubMed
    1. Bottoni CR, Wilckens JH, DeBerardino TM, D'Alleyrand JG, Rooney RC, Harpstrite JK, et al. A prospective, randomized evaluation of arthroscopic stabilization versus nonoperative treatment of acute, traumatic, first‐time shoulder dislocations. In: Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons; 2001 Feb 28‐Mar 4; San Francisco (CA). http://www.aaos.org/wordhtml/anmt2001/sciprog/201.htm (accessed 13/03/03). - PubMed
Kirkley 1999 {published and unpublished data}
    1. Edmonds G, Kirkley A, Birmingham TB, Fowler PJ. The effect of early arthroscopic stabilization compared to nonsurgical treatment on proprioception after primary traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy 2003;11(2):116‐21. - PubMed
    1. Griffin S. personal communication February 18 2005.
    1. Kirkley A, Edmonds G, Fowler PJ. The effect of early arthroscopic stabilization compared to immobilization and rehabilitation on proprioception of the shoulder after primary traumatic anterior dislocation [abstract]. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British Volume 1998;80 Suppl 1:16.
    1. Kirkley A, Griffin S, Miniaci A, Mohtadi N. Prospective randomized clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of immediate arthroscopic stabilization versus immobilization and rehabilitation in first traumatic anterior dislocations of the shoulder [abstract]. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British Volume 2000;82 Suppl 2:157. - PubMed
    1. Kirkley A, Griffin S, Miniaci A, Mohtadi N. Prospective randomized clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of immediate arthroscopic stabilization versus immobilization and rehabilitation in first traumatic anterior dislocations of the shoulder [abstract]. Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery 1999;8(2):181. - PubMed
Sandow 1996 {published data only}
    1. Sandow M, Liu SH. Acute arthroscopic Bankart repair for initial anterior shoulder dislocation: A prospective clinical trial [abstract]. Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery 1996;5(2 Pt 2):S81.
    1. Sandow MJ. Arthroscopic repair for primary shoulder dislocation: A randomized clinical trial [abstract]. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British Volume 1995;77(Suppl 1):67.
Wintzell 1999 {published data only}
    1. Wintzell G, Haglund Akerlind Y, Novak J, Larsson S. Arthroscopic lavage compared with nonoperative treatment for traumatic primary anterior shoulder dislocation: A 2‐year follow‐up of a prospective randomized study. Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery 1999;8(5):399‐402. - PubMed
    1. Wintzell G, Haglund Akerlind Y, Tidermark J, Wredmark T, Eriksson E. A prospective controlled randomized study of arthroscopic lavage in acute primary anterior dislocation of the shoulder: one‐year follow‐up. Knee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy 1996;4(1):43‐7. - PubMed
    1. Wintzell G, Haglund Y, Tidermark J, Wredmark T, Eriksson E. Arthroscopic lavage in acute traumatic primary anterior dislocation of the shoulder. A prospective randomised study [abstract]. Surgery of the Shoulder: Proceedings of the 6th International Congress on Surgery of the Shoulder; 1995 June 27‐July 1 and 2‐4 July; Helsinki and Stockholm. Elsevier Science, 1995:225.
    1. Wintzell G, Haglund‐Akerlind Y, Ekelund A, Sandstrom B, Hovelius L, Larsson S. Arthroscopic lavage reduced the recurrence rate following primary anterior shoulder dislocation. A randomised multicentre study with 1‐year follow‐up. Knee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy 1999;7(3):192‐6. - PubMed
    1. Wintzell G, Haglund‐Akerlind Y, Tengvar M, Johansson L, Eriksson E. MRI examination of the glenohumeral joint after traumatic primary anterior dislocation. A descriptive evaluation of the acute lesion and at 6‐month follow‐up. Knee Surgery Sports Traumatology Arthroscopy 1996;4(4):232‐6. - PubMed

References to studies excluded from this review

Arciero 1994 {published data only}
    1. Arciero RA, Wheeler JH, Ryan JB, McBride JT. Arthroscopic Bankart repair versus nonoperative treatment for acute, initial anterior shoulder dislocations. American Journal of Sports Medicine 1994;22(5):589‐94. - PubMed
DeBerardino 2001 {published data only}
    1. DeBerardino TM, Arciero RA, Taylor DC, Uhorchak JM. Prospective evaluation of arthroscopic stabilization of acute, initial anterior shoulder dislocations in young athletes. Two‐ to five‐year follow‐up. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2001;29(5):586‐92. - PubMed
Jakobsen 1996 {published data only}
    1. Jakobsen BW. personal communication June 21 2004.
    1. Jakobsen BW, Johannsen HV, Suder P, Sojbjerg JO. Primary repair versus conservative treatment of first‐time traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder: a randomized study with 10‐year follow‐up. Arthroscopy 2007;23(2):118‐23. - PubMed
    1. Jakobsen BW, Sojberg JO. Primary repair after traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder joint [abstract]. Orthopaedic Transactions 1997;21(4):1259‐60.
    1. Jakobsen BW, Sojbjerg JO. Primary repair after traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder joint [abstract]. Acta Orthopaedica Scandinavica. Supplementum 1996;272:13.
    1. Suder P, Jakobsen B, Danish Society for Shoulder and Elbow Surgery. Results of conservative treatment of traumatic primary anterior shoulder dislocation correlated to initial arthroscopic findings ‐ a prospective study of 39 young patients [abstract]. Acta Orthopaedica Scandinavica. Supplementum 1997;274:33.
Kulkarni 2003 {published data only}
    1. Kulkarni R. Welsh acute shoulder dislocation project. National Research Register (NRR) Archive. Available from https://portal.nihr.ac.uk/Profiles/NRR.aspx?Publication_ID=M0054049707. [NRR ID: M0054049707]
Robinson 2008 {published data only}
    1. Helms K. Traumatic first‐time anterior dislocation of the shoulder ‐ How should it be treated? [Vordere schulterluxation: Traumatische erstluxation der Schulter ‐ Was soll man tun?]. Zeitschrift fur Orthopadie und Unfallchirurgie 2008;146(3):301. [EMBASE: 2008363257]
    1. Robinson CM, Jenkins PJ, White TO, Ker A, Will E. Primary arthroscopic stabilization for a first‐time anterior dislocation of the shoulder. A randomized, double‐blind trial. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery. American Volume 2008;90(4):708‐21. - PubMed
    1. White T. Acute shoulder stabilisation using endoscopic techniques ‐ ASSET. National Research Register (NRR) Archive. Available from https://portal.nihr.ac.uk/Profiles/NRR.aspx?Publication_ID=N0519110939.
Trimmings 1985 {published data only}
    1. Trimmings NP. Haemarthrosis aspiration in treatment of anterior dislocation of the shoulder. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 1985;78(12):1023‐7. - PMC - PubMed
Yanmis 2003 {published and unpublished data}
    1. Yanmis I, Tunay S, Komurcu M, Yildiz C, Tunay VB, Gur E. Outcomes of acute arthroscopic repair and conservative treatment following first traumatic dislocation of the shoulder joint in young patients. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore 2003;32(6):824‐7. - PubMed

Additional references

Altman 2003
    1. Altman DG, Bland JM. Interaction revisited: the difference between two estimates. BMJ 2003;326(7382):219. - PMC - PubMed
Bankart 1938
    1. Bankart AS. The pathology and treatment of recurrent dislocation of the shoulder joint. British Journal of Surgery 1938;26(101):23‐9.
Brody 2009
    1. Brophy RH, Marx RG. The treatment of traumatic anterior instability of the shoulder: nonoperative and surgical treatment. Arthroscopy 2009;25(3):298‐304. - PubMed
Cox 2008
    1. Cox CL, Kuhn JE. Operative versus nonoperative treatment of acute shoulder dislocation in the athlete. Current Sports Medicine Reports 2008;7(5):263‐8. - PubMed
Davy 2002
    1. Davy AR, Drew SJ. Management of shoulder dislocation ‐ are we doing enough to reduce the risk of recurrence?. Injury 2002;33(9):775‐9. - PubMed
De Palma 1983
    1. Palma AF. Surgery of the shoulder. 3rd Edition. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1983. [ISBN:0397504926]
DeBerardino 2001a
    1. DeBerardino TM, Arciero RA, Taylor DC, Uhorchak JM. Prospective evaluation of arthroscopic stabilization of acute, initial anterior shoulder dislocations in young athletes. Two‐ to five‐year follow‐up. American Journal of Sports Medicine 2001;29(5):586‐92. - PubMed
Fleega 1991
    1. Fleega B. Operation for a recurrent dislocation. In: Watson MS editor(s). Surgical disorders of the shoulder. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1991:339‐51. [ISBN: 0443038899]
Freudmann 2004
    1. Freudmann M, Hay S. The UK shoulder surgeon's approach to traumatic, anterior shoulder dislocation in young patient [abstract]. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British Volume 2004;86(Suppl 1):98.
Goss 1988
    1. Goss TP. Anterior glenohumeral instability. Orthopedics 1988;11(1):87‐95. - PubMed
Handoll 2006
    1. Handoll HHG, Hanchard NCA, Goodchild L, Feary J. Conservative management following closed reduction of traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2006, Issue 1. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD004962.pub2] - DOI - PubMed
Hawkins 1991
    1. Hawkins RJ, Mohtadi GH. Controversy in anterior shoulder instability. Clinical Orthopedics and Related Research 1991;(272):152‐61. - PubMed
Helms 2008
    1. Helms K. Traumatic first‐time anterior dislocation of the shoulder ‐ How should it be treated? [Vordere schulterluxation: Traumatische erstluxation der Schulter ‐ Was soll man tun?]. Zeitschrift fur Orthopadie und Unfallchirurgie 2008;146(3):301. [EMBASE: 2008363257]
Higgins 2003
    1. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. Measuring inconsistency in meta‐analyses. BMJ 2003;327(7414):557‐60. - PMC - PubMed
Higgins 2006
    1. Higgins JPT, Green S, editors. Highly sensitive search strategies for identifying reports of randomized controlled trials in MEDLINE. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions 4.2.6 [updated September 2006]; Appendix 5b. Available from www.cochrane.org/resources/handbook/Handbook4.2.6Sep2006.pdf.
Hill 1940
    1. Hill HA, Sachs MD. The grooved defect of the humeral head: A frequently unrecognised complication of dislocations of the shoulder joint. Radiology 1940;35:690‐700.
Hovelius 1982
    1. Hovelius L. Incidence of shoulder dislocation in Sweden. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 1982;(166):127‐31. - PubMed
Hovelius 1996
    1. Hovelius L, Augustini BG, Fredin H, Johansson O, Norlin R, Thorling J. Primary anterior shoulder dislocation of the shoulder in young patients. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. American Volume 1996;78(11):1677‐84. - PubMed
Jakobsen 2007
    1. Jakobsen BW, Johannsen HV, Suder P, Sojbjerg JO. Primary repair versus conservative treatment of first‐time traumatic anterior dislocation of the shoulder: a randomized study with 10‐year follow‐up. Arthroscopy 2007;23(2):118‐23. - PubMed
Kazar 1969
    1. Kazar B, Relovsky E. Prognosis of primary dislocation of the shoulder. Acta Orthopaedica Scandinavica 1969;40(2):216‐24. - PubMed
Kim 2003
    1. Kim SH, Ha KI, Cho YB, Ryu BD, Oh I. Arthroscopic anterior stabilization of the shoulder: two to six‐year follow‐up. Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery. American Volume 2003;85(8):1511‐8. - PubMed
Kirkley 1997
    1. Kirkley A, Griffin S, Richards C, Mohtadi N, Miniaci A. Prospective randomised clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of immediate arthroscopic stabilization versus immobilization and rehabilitation in first traumatic anterior dislocations of the shoulder [abstract]. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine 1997;7:242. - PubMed
Kirkley 1998
    1. Kirkley A, Griffin S, McLintock H, Ng L. The development and evaluation of a disease‐specific quality of life measurement tool for shoulder instability. American Journal of Sports Medicine 1998;26(6):764‐72. - PubMed
L'Insalata 1997
    1. L'Insalata JC, Warren RF, Cohen SB, Altchek DW, Peterson MG. A self‐administered questionnaire for assessment of symptoms and function of the shoulder. The Western Ontario Shoulder Instability Index (WOSI). Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. American Volume 1997;79(5):738‐48. [MEDLINE: ] - PubMed
Mohtadi 2007
    1. Mohtadi N. Open repair reduced recurrent dislocation more than conservative treatment after traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation [commentary]. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. American Volume 2007;89(8):1871. - PubMed
Morrey 1981
    1. Morrey BF, Chao EX. Recurrent anterior dislocation of the shoulder. In: Black J, Dumbleton JH editor(s). Clinical biomechanics: a case history approach. New York: Churchill Livingstone, 1981:24‐46. [ISBN ‐ 0443080224]
O'Brien 1987
    1. O'Brien SJ, Warren RF, Schwartz EA. Anterior shoulder instability. Orthopedic Clinics of North America 1987;18(3):395‐408. - PubMed
Padua 2007
    1. Padua R, Bondi R, Bondi L, Campi A. Surgical versus conservative treatment for acute first‐time anterior shoulder dislocation: The evidence. Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology 2007;8(4):207‐13.
Pulavarti 2009
    1. Pulavarti RS, Symes TH, Rangan A. Surgical interventions for anterior shoulder instability in adults. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2009, Issue 4. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD005077.pub2] - DOI - PubMed
Rowe 1956
    1. Rowe CR. Prognosis in dislocation of the shoulder. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. American Volume 1956;38(5):957‐77. - PubMed
Rowe 1978
    1. Rowe CR, Patel D, Southmayd WW. The Bankart procedure: a long‐term end‐result study. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. American Volume 1978;60(1):1‐16. - PubMed
Simonet 1984
    1. Simonet WT, Melton LJ II, Cofield RH, Ilstrup DM. Incidence of anterior shoulder dislocation in Olmsted County, Minnesota. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 1984;(186):186‐91. - PubMed
White 2003
    1. White T. Acute shoulder stabilisation using endoscopic techniques ‐ ASSET. National Research Register (NRR) Archive. Available from https://portal.nihr.ac.uk/Profiles/NRR.aspx?Publication_ID=N0519110939.
Williams 1999
    1. Williams GN, Gangel TJ, Arciero RA, Uhorchak JM, Taylor DC. Comparison of the Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation method and two shoulder rating scales. Outcomes measures after shoulder surgery. American Journal of Sports Medicine 1999;27(2):214‐21. - PubMed

References to other published versions of this review

Handoll 2004
    1. Handoll HH, Al‐Maiyah MA, Rangan A. Surgical versus non‐surgical treatment for acute anterior shoulder dislocation. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2004, Issue 1. [DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD004325.pub2] - DOI - PMC - PubMed