1990-2001 US general surgery chief resident gastric surgery operative experience: analysis of paradigm shift

Abstract

The almost complete disappearance of benign gastric ulcer disease has led to the perception that there may be an insufficient gastric surgery experience for surgery residents. This study analyzed resident-reported gastric procedure experience by chief residents from U.S. programs. The Resident Statistic Summaries (Report C) for 1990-2001 were compiled and analyzed. Results are expressed as the average number of operations performed per resident, standard deviation (SD), and the percentage (%) of total gastric operative cases. For all gastric-related surgery, the average reported cases per chief resident ranged from 9.8-12.4 with a peak in 1990 and a nadir in 1999; in 2001 the reported case average was 11.3 (SD ranged from 6-8). Over the same interval, vagotomy decreased from 24% in 1990 to 7% in 2001, whereas gastric-reduction operations increased from 5%-34%. Total gastrectomy remained a constant less than 1.0 per chief resident (range 0.6-0.8), whereas partial gastric resection (PGR) was unchanged. The percentage of all types of gastric resections slightly diminished from 34% in 1990 to 29% in 2001. U.S. surgical chief residents report a widely variable experience in gastric surgery over the period analyzed. However, their overall experience has not significantly diminished since 1990 although specific procedural volume has varied.