Strength of accumulating evidence and data monitoring committee decision making

Abstract

The data monitoring committee (DMC) is a vital component of a randomized clinical trial. Its responsibilities include stopping the trial early for extreme results. The decision to stop the trial must be based on a careful synthesis of statistical methodology and clinical judgment. It is critical to ensure the validity of this complex process. In this paper we present results of a survey of 21 DMC members conducted to investigate how they evaluate accumulating evidence. The results indicate that some DMC members may be over-interpreting developing trends in the data.