Transumbilical approach for shunt insertion in the pediatric population: an improvement in cosmetic results

Abstract

Objective: In spite of the recent interest in endoscopic third ventriculostomy, ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt is still the gold standard in treating non-obstructive hydrocephalus in children. The peritoneal cavity remains the optimal site for cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) diversion. Shunt insertion and re-interventions carry a high risk of inaesthetic abdominal scars and long-term morbidity. We report a technique of transumbilical shunt insertion, which provides better cosmetic results and without many more complications. This approach has been performed for a long period in a wide variety of intra-abdominal conditions by pediatric surgeons.

Methods: Between March and October 2003, we inserted 12 VP shunts in children. For eight consecutively treated children the follow-up is more than 3 months. All the shunts were inserted through the umbilicus. These eight children are the subjects of this study. Indications for shunting were: communicating hydrocephalus (6 cases), subdural hematoma (1 case), and hygroma associated with an arachnoid cyst (1 case). The population consisted of 7 boys and 1 girl, ranging in age between 6 weeks and 47 months (mean age: 15 months), and their body weights varied between 2,110 g and 18,000 g (mean weight: 8,470 g). All children were examined twice a day for 3 days, and wounds were examined daily to check for the absence of sepsis or dehiscence. Clinical controls were performed 1 month after discharge. The operating surgeon was invited to comment on any difficulties encountered in making or closing this incision afterwards.

Results: The average length of clinical follow-up was 6 months (range 4-7 months). One infection of the VP shunt occurred. It was treated with external drainage and antibiotics. After 1 week, a second VP shunt was inserted using the same technique without particular difficulty and with a nice cosmetic result. Concerning the seven other children, the cosmetic results were optimal, with no puckered abdominal scars or wound dehiscence, and with no perioperative or long-term complications related to the umbilical approach.

Conclusion: At this early follow-up, umbilical incision for shunt insertion is a safe and easy technique. It provides an optimal cosmetic result, even in cases of re-intervention. This minimally invasive surgery does not require long specialized training. We have not shown an increase in complications associated with a "learning curve." Longer follow-up is needed to evaluate the risk of infection.