Tension-free repair versus modified Bassini technique (Andrews technique) for strangulated inguinal hernia: a comparative study

Abstract

Background: To compare tension-free hernia repair to a modified Bassini technique (Andrew's technique) used to treat complicated inguinal hernia.

Methods: In the period 1990-2004, 75 patients were submitted to emergency operation because of strangulated inguinal hernia. 33 patients underwent tension-free repair utilizing a polypropylene mesh (group A), whereas the remaining 42 patients underwent a modified Bassini technique (group B).

Results: Mean operative time was significantly longer for group B (91.5+/-9.3 min vs 75.7+/-10.5 min, p<0.05). Postoperative hospital stay was also significantly longer in group B compared to group A (10.3+/-3.4 days vs 4.5+/-2.1 days, p<0.01). Postoperative complication rate did not differ significantly between the two groups (5/33, 15.1% vs 5/42, 11.9%, p=n.s.). No mesh had to be removed. At follow-up (mean 9+/-4.2 years), there was one recurrence in group A (1/33, 3%) and two recurrences in group B (2/42, 4.7%) (p=n.s.).

Conclusion: The presence of a strangulated inguinal hernia cannot be considered a contraindication for the use of a prosthetic mesh.