Quality assurance review of death certificates: a pilot study

Abstract

Background: Although quality assurance programs for medical examiners are required by the National Association of Medical Examiners' Inspection and Accreditation Checklist, quality assurance programs specifically targeting death certificate completion have not been addressed. The Fulton County Medical Examiner, Atlanta, GA, has implemented a pilot quality assurance program for death certificate information, and this report contains information about 1 year's experience with the program.

Methods: All death certificates are reviewed by the case medical examiner(s) and chief medical examiner prior to their release to funeral homes. Death certificates with errors are retained for quality assurance and review purposes, and needed corrections are made before death certificates are released. During a 1-year period, death certificates with errors were collected and then reviewed and tabulated by type of error.

Results: Between May 26, 2003, and May 25, 2004, the Fulton County Medical Examiner certified 1267 deaths. Of these, 47 (4%) were found to contain errors that were corrected and an additional 52 (4%) had been amended for various reasons. The most common errors were misspellings in causes of death or poor or incomplete wording in injury-related information. Forty-seven percent of errors involved omitted, incomplete, or incorrect information that was potentially significant. The most common reason for amended certificates was unexpected detection of acute intoxications among people with significant cardiovascular disease.

Conclusions: Quality assurance review of death certificates can assist in preventing the release of death certificates with incomplete, erroneous, or omitted information and may also be useful as an educational forum regarding completion of the death certificate.