Influence of intrinsic sympathomimetic activity and cardioselectivity on beta adrenoceptor blockade

Abstract

Dose-response curves for propranolol and oxprenolol were studied in healthy volunteers, with a standardized excercise test and percentage reduction in excercise heart rate (EHR) as the index of drug effect. The dose-response curves obtained were compared with similar curves previously reported for sotalol, practolol, and atenolol with identical experimental methods. Two distinct types of response were identified: in the first, shown by propranolol and sotalol, increasing doses of the beta adrenoceptor-blocking drug continued to produce increasing effects to the limits of the dose levels examined; with the second (oxprenolol and practolol), increasing the dose initially resulted in substantial increase in effect but subsequently larger doses produced almost no increase in effect. Consideration of the additional properties of these beta adrenoceptor-blocking drugs revealed that both practolol and oxprenolol have intrinsic sympathomimetric activity (ISA), whereas propranolol and sotalol do not. In addition, practolol is cardioselective. Further investigation of the possible influence of ISA or cardioselectivity on beta adrenoceptor-blocking activity was undertaken by studying the effects of combinations of drugs on EHR. Sotalol produced greater effect when given 2 hr after sotalol, oxprenolol, practolol, or atenolol. When oxprenolol was given after sotalol or oxprenolol, or practolol was given after sotalol or practolol, there was no further increase in percentage reduction in EHR. When atenolol was given, the combinations of sotalol and atenolol together with two doses either of sotalol or atenolol all induced increases and similar final percentage reductions in EHR. Thus atenolol induces effects like those of sotalol, which are quite different from those of oxprenolol or practolol. The presence or absence of ISA would appear to be the important difference between these two groups of drugs: ISA would, therefore, appear to be demonstrated in man by flattening of the dose-response curves with exercise.