Smoking and the patency of lower extremity bypass grafts: a meta-analysis

Abstract

Objective: Smoking is the major risk factor associated with the development and progression of peripheral arterial disease (PAD). To establish the best estimate of the effect of smoking, smoking cessation, and the dose-response relationship on the patency of lower extremity bypass grafts, we performed a systematic review.

Methods: A search of medical articles and reviews relating to the influence of smoking on the patency of arterial reconstructive grafts in patients with PAD was made. Studies considered for inclusion were those that evaluated the influence of smoking on the primary, secondary, or cumulative patency rates of arterial reconstructive surgery in the lower extremities in patients with PAD. Primary data were used to calculate summary estimates with standard meta-analysis techniques.

Results: The 29 eligible studies included 4 randomized clinical trials, 12 prospective studies, and 13 retrospective studies. The effect of smoking on graft patency in the randomized clinical trials and other prospective studies had a 3.09-fold (2.34 to 4.08; P < .00001) increase in graft failure. A comparison of patency rates among all studies that used autogenous or polyester grafts showed no difference. A clear dose-response relationship was present, with a decreased patency in heavy smokers compared with moderate smokers. Smoking cessation restores patency rates toward the never smokers group.

Conclusion: Continued smoking after lower limb bypass surgery results in a threefold increased risk of graft failure. Smoking cessation, even if instigated after the operation, restored graft patency towards the patency of never smokers. These results indicate that adequate smoking cessation strategies in patients eligible for lower limb bypass surgery are of utmost importance.