Phenytoin: an anti-bipolar anticonvulsant?

Abstract

Phenytoin, a classical anticonvulsant has been little studied in bipolar disorder. We completed a trial of phenytoin in mania and schizoaffective disorder, manic type. Thirty-nine patients entered a 5-wk double-blind controlled trial of haloperidol+phenytoin vs. haloperidol+placebo; 30 patients completed at least 3 wk; 25 completed 5 wk. Significantly more improvement was observed in those patients receiving phenytoin. Phenytoin has not previously been studied prophylactically in bipolar patients. Bipolar patients were studied who had at least one episode per year in the previous 2 yr despite ongoing prophylaxis. Patients were stable for a mean of 4 months (range 1-13) before entering the study. Phenytoin or placebo was added to their current therapy in a double-blind cross-over design for 6 months in each phase. Thirty observation periods of 6 months each were studied for 23 patients. Three patients had relapse on phenytoin and nine had relapse on placebo. There was a significant prophylactic effect of phenytoin in bipolar disorder [Cox's F test for comparing survival in two groups: F(6, 18)=3.44, p=0.02]. This study suggests prophylactic effects of add-on phenytoin in bipolar illness. However, the number of patients was small and confirmation is necessary. Lamotrigine has recently been reported to have antidepressant effects. In the past, small studies showed antidepressant effects for carbamazepine and valproate. To determine if such effects could be a class property of other voltage-activated sodium channel blockers such as phenytoin, we performed a double-blind controlled trial of phenytoin vs. fluoxetine in unipolar depression. Thirty-three depressed patients entered the study, and 28 completed at least 3 weeks and were included in data analyses. Weekly Hamilton Depression Scales for 6 wk showed no difference between fluoxetine and phenytoin. Clearly pharmaceutical company funding for clinical trials or advertising for phenytoin is minimal and this must be taken into account in evaluating literature on phenytoin vs. other drugs. The present data suggests that effects on affective disorder may be common to many anticonvulsants.