Assessment of depression in medically ill children presenting to pediatric specialty clinics

Abstract

Objective: Self-report measures of depression may be inaccurate when applied to medically ill children because of the overlap between medical and psychiatric symptoms. The American Academy of Pediatrics endorses the use of self-reports as diagnostic aids (used in patients who are suspected of having an emotional problem by their pediatricians). This approach has not been validated. We evaluated the diagnostic accuracy of the Children's Depression Inventory (CDI) in medically ill children who were referred for evaluation by their pediatricians.

Method: The evaluation included the CDI and a best estimate diagnostic procedure that incorporated results from semistructured and other interviews. Evaluators were not aware of the CDI scores when making a diagnostic determination.

Results: One hundred twenty-five patients, 8-19 years old, were referred between September 2000 and May 2003. Eighty-one completed the diagnostic procedure. The CDI summary score performed well in identifying best estimate depressive disorder determinations in this cohort. A cutoff of 11 and above correctly identified 80% of cases, with a specificity of 70%.

Discussion: A self-report measure of depression (CDI) could be used as a diagnostic aid in medically ill children who are suspected of having an emotional problem by their pediatricians. This finding supports the "two-tier" depression screening approach endorsed by the American Academy of Pediatrics for use in pediatricians' offices.