Primary liver cancer in non-cirrhotic liver. Epidemiological study based on autopsies performed in Trieste, Italy and Kurume, Japan

Abstract

This study, aimed at elucidating the epidemiological features of primary liver carcinoma developing in non-cirrhotic livers, was based on 25,103 autopsies performed between 1975 and 1984 in Trieste, Italy. These autopsies correspond to approximately 70% of all deaths that occurred in this area. Various factors allegedly related to carcinomas were analysed in reference to our previous study on cirrhotic livers and in comparison with 5,603 autopsies in Kurume, Japan. There were 28 cases of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), 16 of cholangiocellular carcinoma (CCC) not associated with cirrhosis in Trieste, and 48 HCC and 19 CCC in Kurume. On the basis of our findings, it was concluded that cirrhosis, regardless of its cause, is the main pathogenetic factor in HCC; it is responsible for a much higher frequency (14.2:1) than in non-cirrhotic livers, as well as for early occurrence of tumours (an average of 6 years earlier in cirrhotic liver) in Trieste. Patients in Trieste were older than those in Japan, and the frequency of HCC among all autopsies was much greater in the latter. By contrast, the influence of cirrhosis on cholangiocellular carcinoma (CCC) was negligible, as such association appeared purely coincidental or absent. The incidence of CCC among autopsies was greater in Japan. Our data on CCC were not sufficient to demonstrate any clear aetiopathogenetic association between this tumour and alcohol abuse and hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection, except for a possible aetiological role of gallstones. The frequency of CCC relative to HCC was greater in Trieste than in Japan; the incidence of HCC was much less in Trieste, whereas CCC was more frequent in Japan.