Naturally occurring mutations within HIV-1 V3 genomic RNA lead to antigenic variation dependent on a single amino acid substitution

Abstract

In a study on the evolution of genomic diversity of HIV-1, genomic RNA was isolated from serum of two individuals. Starting at the time of primary infection we collected six samples of serum from each patient over a period of 5 years. Ninety-four cDNA clones (50 of patient 1 and 44 of patient 495) of part of the envelope coding region including the principal neutralization domain (PND) were sequenced. Around the time of antibody seroconversion, genomic RNA levels reached a peak and the population of sequences was highly homogeneous. In the course of the infection, the number of amino acid substitutions accumulated, which led to a higher genomic diversity within successive samples and a drift in the consensus sequence, progressively differing from the first found consensus sequence. Fixation of a substitution at glycoprotein 120 amino acid 308 was observed in both patients between two time points (patient 1, H----P; patient 495, P----H). With the use of 16-meric synthetic peptides, differing only at the 308 position (H308 versus P308), antibody binding specificity was found to be dependent on this difference. In patient 495, the nonconservative (P308----H) substitution reduced the binding affinity with the patient's antibodies. Furthermore, antibody competition assays showed that the observed substitution at position 308 elicited a new antibody population, indicating antigenic variation. After the decline of V3-specific antibodies, the simultaneous increase in genomic RNA levels and progression to AIDS in patient 495, a new variant with major changes in the PND emerged, again forming a homogeneous population of sequences.