Phenotypic commonalities in familial and sporadic Parkinson disease

Abstract

Background: Parkinson disease (PD) is a clinically well-documented neurodegenerative disorder. However, the mechanism or mechanisms of its phenotypic expressions are still unknown.

Objective: To compare phenotypes by examining demographic and clinical features of patients with familial PD and sporadic PD and with or without a family history of PD.

Design: Historical review of patients with sporadic PD in clinic-based samples and individual patients diagnosed with PD from families whose linkage to mutations or loci has been identified.

Setting: Movement disorder clinic in a referral center.

Patients: A total of 1277 patients with sporadic PD and 40 patients with familial PD.

Main outcome measures: Clinical features, including distribution by sex, initial motor symptom, location of initial motor symptom, and frequency of asymmetric motor symptoms.

Results: Despite different etiologic backgrounds, both familial and sporadic PD exhibited several interesting commonalities, including a higher incidence in men, tremor as the initial motor symptom (predominantly involving the upper extremities), and asymmetric parkinsonism during disease course.

Conclusions: The increased incidence of parkinsonism in men with familial PD suggests that the sex disparity is more likely the result of a protective effect against development of PD in women than of an increased risk in men that is associated with environmental factors. Phenotypic similarity among familial and sporadic PD indicates that a similar topographic distribution of the nigrostriatal lesion exists in patients with either form of PD regardless of apparent genetic influence.