Analysis of synergism/antagonism between HIV-1 antibody-positive human sera and soluble CD4 in blocking HIV-1 binding and infectivity

Abstract

We tested human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) antibody-positive human sera and sCD4, alone and in combination, for synergistic, additive, or antagonistic effects on blocking of HIV binding and infectivity. Data were analyzed by an application of the median effect principle derived from the law of mass action. This allows the assessment of synergism/antagonism at any desired level of effect. Using three assays (whole virus binding to CD4 cells, neutralization of HIV infectivity, and binding of purified gp120 to solid-phase sCD4), we generally observed additive effects or slight synergism between antibody and sCD4 in inhibiting gp120-CD4 interaction. We used a fourth assay to measure the irreversible inactivation of HIV infectivity by sCD4, a property that can also be mediated by antibody but with considerably less potency than sCD4. The reduction in HIV infectivity mediated by mixtures of sCD4 and antibody was always equal to or greater than the arithmetic sum of the reductions by either agent alone. The relevant antiviral effects of sCD4 and anti-HIV sera may include reversible blockage of receptor binding, irreversible inactivation of HIV infectivity, and in the case of antibody, additional reactions that are independent of receptor binding. Although predictions concerning the in vivo situation are speculative, we find no evidence in vitro for antagonism between sCD4 and antibody with respect to the net effect of the two in blocking HIV binding and infectivity.