Extending basic principles of measurement models to the design and validation of Patient Reported Outcomes

Abstract

A recently published article by the Scientific Advisory Committee of the Medical Outcomes Trust presents guidelines for selecting and evaluating health status and health-related quality of life measures used in health outcomes research. In their article, they propose a number of validation and performance criteria with which to evaluate such self-report measures. We provide an alternate, yet complementary, perspective by extending the types of measurement models which are available to the instrument designer. During psychometric development or selection of a Patient Reported Outcome measure it is necessary to determine which, of the five types of measurement models, the measure is based on; 1) a Multiple Effect Indicator model, 2) a Multiple Cause Indicator model, 3) a Single Item Effect Indicator model, 4) a Single Item Cause Indicator model, or 5) a Mixed Multiple Indicator model. Specification of the measurement model has a major influence on decisions about item and scale design, the appropriate application of statistical validation methods, and the suitability of the resulting measure for a particular use in clinical and population-based outcomes research activities.

Figure 1

Causes and Effects of Single or Multiple Observations.

Figure 2

Items comprising the TSQM Convenience Scale.

Figure 3

A general rating scale of 'Current Health' used in the Health Assessment Questionnaire.

Figure 4

A 'Health Status' visual analog scale used in the Health Assessment Questionnaire.

Figure 5

An example of a MMI model of Treatment Satisfaction.