Medial collateral ligament complex of the ankle: MR appearance in asymptomatic subjects

Abstract

Purpose: To prospectively characterize the spin-echo magnetic resonance (MR) imaging appearance of the medial collateral ligament (MCL) complex of the ankle in asymptomatic volunteers.

Materials and methods: The study was approved by institutional review board. Informed consent was obtained. MR images in 56 asymptomatic subjects (29 women, 27 men; mean age, 40.7 years; range, 23-60 years) were analyzed by two musculoskeletal radiologists. Visibility and signal intensity characteristics were analyzed for deep (anterior and posterior tibiotalar ligaments [TTLs]) and superficial (tibionavicular ligament [TNL], tibiospring ligament [TSL], and tibiocalcaneal ligament [TCL]) components of the MCL complex. Thickness of ligaments was compared between sexes (Mann-Whitney U test). Associations between age and variables of signal intensity characteristics and morphology were evaluated with Kruskal-Wallis test.

Results: Anterior and posterior TTLs, TNL, TSL, and TCL were visible in 31 (55%), 56 (100%), 31 (55%), 56 (100%), and 49 (88%) subjects, respectively. On T1-weighted images, anterior and posterior TTLs, TNL, TSL, and TCL were more commonly of intermediate signal intensity than hypointense (77%, 100%, 93%, 50%, and 73% of subjects, respectively); on T2-weighted images, they were commonly hypointense (55%, 52%, 42%, 75%, and 78% of subjects, respectively). On T2-weighted images, posterior TTL had a striated appearance that was significantly associated with age (P = .004) in 89% of subjects: In subjects younger than 45 years, this striated appearance was present. On T1-weighted images, striation was present in 48% of subjects. Striation was uncommon in remaining ligaments. Mean thickness and range were 1.5 mm and 1-4 mm (anterior TTL), 8.2 mm and 6-11 mm (posterior TTL), 1.6 mm and 1-2 mm (TNL), 2.0 mm and 1-4 mm (TSL), and 1.2 mm and 1-3 mm (TCL). TNL (P = .001) and TSL (P = .003) were significantly thicker in men than in women.

Conclusion: In asymptomatic volunteers, posterior TTL and TSL were always visible, but anterior TTL and TNL are only seen in approximately half of subjects. Posterior TTL has a typically striated appearance.