Should the urine PCO2 or the rate of excretion of ammonium be the gold standard to diagnose distal renal tubular acidosis?

Abstract

A high rate of excretion of ammonium (NH4+) during chronic metabolic acidosis should rule out the diagnosis of distal renal tubular acidosis (RTA). Bearing this in mind, the purpose of this report is to demonstrate that a low urine minus blood PCO2 difference in alkaline urine (U-B PCO2) is a less reliable indicator of the diagnosis of distal RTA. The patient who is the subject of this report sniffs glue on a chronic, but intermittent basis. He presented with metabolic acidosis (pH 7.20; bicarbonate, 10 mmol/L) and an anion gap in plasma of 20 mEq/L. The urine anion gap (-14 mEq/L) and osmolal gap (185 mmol/L [mOsm/kg] H2O) suggested that there was a high, rather than a low, rate of excretion of NH4+. This was confirmed by direct measurement of NH4+ in the urine (101 mumol/min). The high rate of excretion of NH4+ suggested that the metabolic acidosis was due, in large part, to an abnormally high rate of production of acid (hippuric acid, because the rate of excretion of hippurate was 76 mumol/min). The U-B PCO2 was low (10 mm Hg) on the second hospital day, after the acidosis was corrected. Potential reasons for the discrepancy between the high rate of excretion of NH4+ and the low U-B PCO2 are discussed.