Sex differences in severe pulmonary emphysema

Abstract

Rationale: Limited data on sex differences in advanced COPD are available.

Objectives: To compare male and female emphysema patients with severe disease.

Methods: One thousand fifty-three patients (38.8% female) evaluated for lung volume reduction surgery as part of the National Emphysema Treatment Trial were analyzed.

Measurements and main results: Detailed clinical, physiological, and radiological assessment, including quantitation of emphysema severity and distribution from helical chest computed tomography, was completed. In a subgroup (n = 101), airway size and thickness was determined by histological analyses of resected tissue. Women were younger and exhibited a lower body mass index (BMI), shorter smoking history, less severe airflow obstruction, lower Dl(co) and arterial Po(2), higher arterial Pco(2), shorter six-minute walk distance, and lower maximal wattage during oxygen-supplemented cycle ergometry. For a given FEV(1)% predicted, age, number of pack-years, and proportion of emphysema, women experienced greater dyspnea, higher modified BODE, more depression, lower SF-36 mental component score, and lower quality of well-being. Overall emphysema was less severe in women, with the difference from men most evident in the outer peel of the lung. Females had thicker small airway walls relative to luminal perimeters.

Conclusions: In patients with severe COPD, women, relative to men, exhibit anatomically smaller airway lumens with disproportionately thicker airway walls, and emphysema that is less extensive and characterized by smaller hole size and less peripheral involvement.

Figure 1.

(A) Relationship of total Beck score (y axis) to age (x axis) when FEV₁% predicted, whole-lung % emphysema proportion, and pack-years are held constant. An interaction of age and sex is evident, and is significant (P = 0.03). (B) Relationship of SF-36 Mental Component Score (y axis) to age (x axis) when FEV₁% predicted, whole-lung % emphysema proportion, and pack-years are held constant. An interaction of age and sex is evident and is significant (P = 0.02).