Ameloblastic fibroma: a review of published studies with special reference to its nature and biological behavior

Abstract

To further elucidate confusions with respect to the nature and biological behavior of ameloblastic fibroma (AF), available English-language literature since its first description in 1891 was reviewed. A total number of 123 cases with well-documented follow-up data were retrieved to evaluate various clinical, pathological and behavioral aspects of this tumor. AF tends to occur in the first two decades (89/123; 72.4%), but patients older than 22 years are not uncommon (30 cases). An overall recurrence rate of 33.3% (41 cases) is identified in reported cases who were treated by conservative (91.5%) and radical (8.5%) methods. Malignant transformation is evident in 14 recurrent tumors with an overall transformation rate of 11.4%. These data support the view that majority of AFs are true neoplasms. However, a small number of AFs occurring in childhood may represent the primitive stage of a developing odontoma, as three of the reported recurrent AFs do show further maturation with formation of dental hard tissues. A significantly longer recurrence-free survival was noted in patients treated by radical procedures in comparison to those treated by conservative methods and the age of patients at the first presentation was significantly related to malignant transformation of AF. As we are unable, at present, to differentiate a hamartomatous lesion from a neoplasm among this group of lesions merely on histologic grounds, age of the patients should be an important consideration when choosing therapeutic methods. Radical surgery should not be employed for the treatment of AFs in young people.