Trochanteric bursitis: refuting the myth of inflammation

Abstract

Background and objectives: Greater trochanteric (GT) bursitis is a common cause of hip pain. Previously, the etiology of the trochanteric pain syndrome was thought to be caused by inflammation of the subgluteus maximus bursa (i.e., bursitis). Recently, MRI and ultrasound studies have brought into serious doubt the idea that bursitis is the etiology for trochanteric pain. To our knowledge, no histologic study of GT bursitis has been reported to date. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the histopathology of patients with and without the clinical syndrome of GT bursitis to assess for the presence of bursal inflammation.

Design and methods: This is a prospective, case-controlled, blinded study of the histopathologic features of controls and patients with GT bursitis. We recruited patients who required total hip arthroplasty (THA) for rheumatoid or osteoarthritis. Inclusion criteria for the study consisted of the following: needing THA as standard of care; THA secondary to OA or RA; age greater than 18; and minimal risk for surgery by the American Heart Association Criteria. We excluded anyone who received a GT bursa injection 9 months before surgery. Eligible participants were then stratified as cases or controls using the 1985 clinical criteria for GT bursitis. The harvesting of the bursa required no modification of the surgical procedure. The specimens were then examined by 2 independent pathologists who were blinded as to the patients' clinical status.

Results: Six bursal specimens were evaluated by 2 blinded surgical pathologists revealing primarily fibroadipose tissue with no signs of acute or chronic inflammation. There were 3 bursas in the control group and 2 specimens with clinical GT bursitis. No significant differences were found between the specimens of the 2 groups.

Conclusions: The results of this small prospective observational histologic study, along with recent MRI and ultrasound studies on the topic, strongly suggest that there is no etiologic role of bursal inflammation in the trochanteric pain syndrome.