Performance of procedures by nephrologists and nephrology fellows at U.S. nephrology training programs

Abstract

Background and objectives: Some procedures (e.g., placement of temporary hemodialysis catheters and kidney biopsies) are required in nephrology fellowship training. Others (e.g., placement of tunneled hemodialysis catheters, ultrasonography, and hemodialysis access interventions) are not required but are performed at some centers. To assess the procedures performed by nephrologists and nephrology fellows at U.S. adult nephrology training programs and the number of procedures required for fellow competency, a survey was conducted of all such training programs.

Design, setting, participants, & measurements: An on-line survey was e-mailed to the directors of all U.S. adult nephrology fellowship programs in October to November 2007.

Results: Responses were received from 93 of 136 programs. Nephrologists and nephrology trainees perform native and transplant kidney biopsies in 98% to 99% of programs and, in about half of programs, also perform the ultrasound guidance. Diagnostic ultrasounds are performed at fewer programs. Temporary dialysis catheters are inserted at nearly all programs. Tunneled hemodialysis catheters and peritoneal dialysis catheters are placed at < or =20% of programs. Interventional procedures on hemodialysis access are performed at 13% to 21% of programs. Continuous renal replacement therapy is performed at 99% of programs, plasmapheresis at 40%. Many programs either do not specify a minimum number of supervised procedures that need to be performed to demonstrate competence or require a very limited number.

Conclusions: Core procedures are performed at almost all programs. Experience and training in other procedures are variable. Many programs have limited requirements for the number of procedures trainees need to perform to demonstrate competence.

Figure 1.

Number of programs reporting specific minimum numbers of procedures required for documentation of competence in insertion of temporary hemodialysis catheters and performance of kidney biopsies.

Figure 2.

Number of programs reporting specific minimum numbers of procedures required for documentation of procedural competence in ultrasound for kidney biopsies and continuous renal replacement therapy (CRRT).