Genome-wide association studies: implications for multiethnic samples

Abstract

The current gene mapping for complex diseases is heavily weighted by studies of population samples from northern Europe. To capture the full range of genetic diversity and exploit the potential of genetic epidemiology to identify important variants, multiple additional populations will need to be examined. The conduct of genome-wide association studies will therefore confront many of the challenges identified in the first generation of candidate gene and linkage studies, with a substantial increase in complexity. Initial efforts to map causal effects will have to take account of varying patterns of linkage disequilibrium through careful attention to local haplotype structure. Refined statistical techniques that permit joint analyses of samples from multiple populations will also be required, as well as improved methods to account for on-going gene flow between populations with geographically distinct ancestral origins. This variation can either be an impediment, slowing the process of replication, or an opportunity, allowing finer dissection of the relevant variants. Clinical translation of these data will present major challenges. Large cosmopolitan populations, such as those found in large urban centers, are likely to exhibit both known and cryptic sub-structure across groups, as well as admixture within individuals. Great care will need to be devoted to generalizability of association findings to avoid their premature adoption as predictive tests in the face of this widespread heterogeneity.

Figure 1.

Haplotype cluster frequencies for 156 consecutive SNPs on chromosome 2 in the region surrounding the LCT gene (136.373–136.478 Mb). At each SNP, relative frequencies of haplotype clusters are displayed on a thin vertical line. Each color depicts a haplotype cluster, and the proportion in a color gives the frequency of 1 of 20 distinct clusters. Interpretation of colors is made locally, as clustering varies along the chromosome, reflecting a gradual decay of LD. Moving horizontally, changes in color patterns illustrate the change in haplotypic composition across physical position. CEU, Utah residents with ancestry from northern and western Europe; CHB, Han Chinese from Beijing; JPT, Japanese from Tokyo; YRI, Yoruba from Ibadan, Nigeria. Reprinted by permission from Macmillan Publishers Ltd: [Nature] (15), © (2008).