Environmental fate and toxicology of carbaryl

Abstract

Carbaryl is an agricultural and garden insecticide that controls a broad spectrum of insects. Although moderately water soluble, it neither vaporizes nor volatilizes readily. However, upon spray application the insecticide is susceptible to drift. It is unstable under alkaline conditions, thus easily hydrolyzed. Carbaryl has been detected in water at ppb concentrations but degradation is relatively rapid, with 1-naphthol identified as the major degradation product. Indirect and direct photolysis of carbaryl produces different naphthoquinones as well as some hydroxyl substituted naphthoquinones. Sorption of the insecticide to soil is kinetically rapid. However, although both the mineral and organic fractions contribute, because of its moderate water solubility it is only minimally sorbed. Also, sorption to soil minerals strongly depends on the presence of specific exchangeable cations and increases with organic matter aromaticity and age. Soil microbes (bacteria and fungi) are capable of degrading carbaryl; the process is more rapid in anoxic than aerobic systems and with increased temperature and moisture. Carbaryl presents a significant problem to pregnant dogs and their offspring, but some have questioned the applicability of these data to humans. In addition, for toxicokinetic and/or physiological reasons, it has been argued that dogs are more sensitive than humans to carbaryl-induced reproductive or developmental toxicity. However, these arguments are based on either older pharmacokinetic studies or on speculation about possible reproductive differences between dogs on the one hand and rats and humans on the other. In view of the wider evidence from both human epidemiological and laboratory animal studies, the question of the possible developmental and reproductive toxicity of carbaryl should be considered open and requiring further study.