Seven-year results with the St Jude Medical Silzone mechanical prosthesis

Abstract

Objective: The Artificial Valve Endocarditis Reduction Trial was stopped on January 21, 2000, due to a higher incidence of paraprosthetic leak in the St Jude Medical Silzone prosthesis compared with the conventional prosthesis. The Artificial Valve Endocarditis Reduction Trial investigators reported the 2-year results in 2002. This retrospective study assessed the influence on thromboembolism and paraprosthetic leak to 7 years.

Methods: A total of 253 patients had 254 operations: 80 aortic valve replacements, 139 mitral valve replacements, and 35 multiple replacements with placement of Silzone prostheses. The mean age was 58.6 years (range 21-84 years, median age 59.8 years), and there were 126 women (49.8%) and 74 concomitant procedures (coronary artery bypass 28.9%).

Results: Major paraprosthetic leak (repair, re-replacement, or mortality) occurred in 10 of the original procedures after 30 days (3 aortic valve replacements, 3 mitral valve replacements, 4 multiple replacements). Nine occurrences in 8 patients-5 early (<or=2 years) and 4 late (>2 years)-were managed. Seven were managed with definitive re-replacement. One was an early nonoperative fatality. There was 1 late fatality after the second late paraprosthetic leak reoperation. One of the 10 procedures occurring after 2 years had mild to moderate aortic valve replacement paraprosthetic leak managed as an incidental re-replacement at the time of correction of supra valvular patch stenosis. One additional occurrence, in addition to the 8 patients (<30 days), was considered a technical error and not related to the Silzone prosthesis and was replaced with a Silzone prosthesis. The linearized rate of paraprosthetic leak within the first 2 years of follow-up was 1.3%/patient-year and after 2 years was 0.4%/patient-year. The linearized occurrence rate for major thromboembolism was 0.42%/patient-year for aortic valve replacement and 1.71%/patient-year for mitral valve replacement.

Conclusions: Paraprosthetic leak with the St Jude Medical Silzone prosthesis was managed both during the early (<or=2 years) and late (>2years) intervals with re-replacement. Late managed events may be manifestations of earlier occurring paraprosthetic leak. Follow-up echocardiograms should meet standards of care, 6 to 12 months after surgery and at the slightest suspicion of dysfunction. There is no advanced continuing risk of the St Jude Medical Silzone prosthesis.