Low sensitivity in clinical diagnoses of dementia with Lewy bodies

Abstract

The success of future neurodegenerative disease (ND) therapies depends partly on accurate antemortem diagnoses. Relatively few prior studies have been performed on large, multicenter-derived datasets to test the accuracy of final clinical ND diagnoses in relation to definitive neuropathological findings. Data were analyzed from the University of Kentucky Alzheimer's Disease Center autopsy series and from the National Alzheimer's Coordinating Center (NACC) registry. NACC data are derived from 31 different academic medical centers, each with strong clinical expertise and infrastructure pertaining to NDs. The final clinical diagnoses were compared systematically with subsequent neuropathology diagnoses. Among subjects meeting final inclusion criteria (N = 2,861 for NACC Registry data), the strength of the associations between clinical diagnoses and subsequent ND diagnoses was only moderate. This was particularly true in the case of dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB): the sensitivity of clinical diagnoses was quite low (32.1% for pure DLB and 12.1% for Alzheimer's disease (AD + DLB) although specificity was over 95%. AD clinical diagnoses were more accurate (85.0% sensitivity and 51.1% specificity). The accuracy of clinical DLB diagnoses became somewhat lower over the past decade, due apparently to increased "over-calling" the diagnosis in patients with severe cognitive impairment. Furthermore, using visual hallucinations, extrapyramidal signs, and/or fluctuating cognition as part of the clinical criteria for DLB diagnosis was of minimal utility in a group (N = 237) with high prevalence of severe dementia. Our data suggest that further work is needed to refine our ability to identify specific aging-related brain disease mechanisms, especially in DLB.

Fig. 1

According to NACC Registry data, the tendency to “under-call” or “over-call” neocortical Lewy bodies (LBs) has increased in recent years (p < 0.0053 for any mis-call; Chi-square test). The definitions of clinically “under-calling” or “over-calling” neocortical LBs are presented on Table 1

Fig. 2

Analyses of the NACC Registry data allow the correlation between particular patients' final mini-mental status examination (MMSE) scores and the clinicians' tendency to “under-call” or “over-call” neocortical Lewy bodies (LBs). There is an apparent tendency to over-call neocortical LBs in severe dementia patients. The definitions of clinically “under-calling” or “over-calling” neocortical LBs are presented on Table 1