Microsurgical excision of colloid cyst with favorable cognitive outcomes and short operative time and hospital stay: operative techniques and analyses of outcomes with review of previous studies

Abstract

Objective: Microsurgical and endoscopic colloid cyst excision differ with regard to operative time, length of hospital stay, and extent of resection.

Methods: A retrospective review of a single surgeon's microsurgical colloid cyst resection in 10 consecutive patients was performed. Cyst size, hydrocephalus, symptoms, operative time, postoperative stay, complications, and objective testing of memory, concentration, calculation, and attention (cognition), along with performance at job, were noted.

Results: All 10 patients had complete excision. Mean cyst size, mean operative time, and median postoperative stay were 1.6 cm, 124 minutes, and 3.5 days respectively. The mean operative time from cyst visualization to complete excision was 18 minutes. Follow-up ranged from 6 to 111 months (mean, 49.5 months). There were no recurrences; symptoms (headache, visual and balance problems) improved significantly in 70%. Postoperative cognitive performance, including memory, was the same in 8 patients (5 of whom had preoperative memory problems) and worse in 2 patients who had no preoperative memory problems. The bone flap was removed in 1 patient for wound dehiscence. Hemiparesis in another patient, seen immediately after surgery, completely resolved before discharge. One patient with loculated ventricles and multiple previous shunt revisions had unresolved hydrocephalus after cyst excision.

Conclusion: We report the very short operative times and postoperative stay for microsurgery, which are comparable to some endoscopic series. We also report results of objective tests of cognitive performance. With adoption of a callosal incision of 1 cm or less, meticulous dissection around the fornix, and complete excision, acceptable long-term cognitive function and functional performance were achieved. Our results support the microsurgical approach. A larger sample size can more conclusively establish whether it should be chosen over the endoscopic technique.