Reproductive performance, udder health, and antibiotic resistance in mastitis bacteria isolated from Norwegian Red cows in conventional and organic farming

Abstract

Background: The objectives of this study were to investigate whether there were differences between Norwegian Red cows in conventional and organic farming with respect to reproductive performance, udder health, and antibiotic resistance in udder pathogens.

Methods: Twenty-five conventional and 24 organic herds from south-east and middle Norway participated in the study. Herds were matched such that geographical location, herd size, and barn types were similar across the cohorts. All organic herds were certified as organic between 1997 and 2003. All herds were members of the Norwegian Dairy Herd Recording System. The herds were visited once during the study. The relationship between the outcomes and explanatory variables were assessed using mixed linear models.

Results: There were less > 2nd parity cows in conventional farming. The conventional cows had higher milk yields and received more concentrates than organic cows. Although after adjustment for milk yield and parity, somatic cell count was lower in organic cows than conventional cows. There was a higher proportion of quarters that were dried off at the herd visit in organic herds. No differences in the interval to first AI, interval to last AI or calving interval was revealed between organic and conventional cows. There was no difference between conventional and organic cows in quarter samples positive for mastitis bacteria from the herd visit. Milk yield and parity were associated with the likelihood of at least one quarter positive for mastitis bacteria. There was few S. aureus isolates resistance to penicillin in both management systems. Penicillin resistance against Coagulase negative staphylococci isolated from subclinically infected quarters was 48.5% in conventional herds and 46.5% in organic herds.

Conclusion: There were no large differences between reproductive performance and udder health between conventional and organic farming for Norwegian Red cows.

Figure 1

Lactation curves for milk yield. Predicted test-day milk yield (kg/d) by WIM for 1st (organic = black triangle, conventional = white triangle) and > 2nd (organic = black circle, conventional = white circle) parity cows in conventional and organic farming.

Figure 2

Lactation curves for concentrate allocation. Concentrate allocation [MJ/d] by WIM for 1st (organic = black triangle, conventional = white triangle) and > 2nd (organic = black circle, conventional = white circle) parity cows in conventional and organic farming.

Figure 3

Lactation curves for SCC. Test-day somatic cell count (SCC) by WIM for 1st (organic = black triangle, conventional = white triangle) and > 2nd (organic = black circle, conventional = white circle) parity cows in conventional and organic farming.