Persistence of adenovirus nucleic acids in nasopharyngeal secretions: a diagnostic conundrum

Abstract

Background: Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays increase the rate of viral detection in clinical specimens, compared with conventional virologic methods. Studies suggest that PCR may detect virus nucleic acid (NA) that persists in the respiratory tract.

Methods: We analyzed virologic data from children having frequent upper respiratory infections (URI), who were followed up in a longitudinal study. Nasopharyngeal secretions were collected at URI onset and when acute otitis media was diagnosed; virus studies were performed using conventional diagnostics and PCR. Repeated presence of adenovirus by PCR was further studied by sequencing and phylogenetic analysis.

Results: Of 581 URI episodes in 76 children, 510 viruses were detected. Of the viruses detected by PCR, 15% were those detected previously; repeated positives occurred most frequently with adenovirus. Sequencing results were available in 13 children with repeated adenovirus detection; the following 4 patterns of infection were identified (16 instances): (1) adenovirus of the same serotype and strain detected continuously (n = 8 instances), (2) adenovirus of different serotypes detected during sequential URI episodes (n = 3), (3) adenovirus of the same serotype but different strains detected during sequential URI episodes (n = 3), and (4) adenovirus of the same serotype and strain detected intermittently (n = 2).

Conclusions: Among children with frequent URIs, repeated positive PCR results for adenovirus NA may represent a new serotype/strain, or persistence of viral NA. Results must be interpreted with caution; clinical correlation and presence of other viruses are important. Further longitudinal studies of children during and after infection are required for better understanding of the clinical significance of positive PCR tests for adenovirus NA in the respiratory tract.

Figure 1a

Case 1- A child with repeated episodes of URI with the same adenovirus serotype and strain which persisted for 203 days after initial identification.

Figure 1b

Case 2- A child with repeated episodes of URI with two different serotypes of adenovirus, one of which re-emerged 127 days after the first episode

Figure 1c

Case 3- A child with repeated episodes of URI with two different serotypes of adenovirus and two different strains of the same serotype.

Figure 1d

Case 4- A child with repeated episodes of URI with the same adenovirus serotype but different strains.